Thurs. May 25 - Think about our class list of
reasons for having public schools in light of the Labaree article…does the list
jibe with his three categories? Has he left anything out? Any other thoughts?
Although Labaree does touch on some of our class list of reasons for having public schools, he leaves out most of the points we emphasized in class. Labaree's first category, which he calls democratic equality, is an idea he shares with our class list. The main point of the idea is that political competence is necessary in democratic societies and one of the many goals of public schools is to promote values that create good citizens. An aspect of democratic equality that Labaree leaves out is the importance of equal opportunities. Labaree highlights political equality, specifically one person, one vote, but he neglects to mention the lack of equality in level of education and prospects for the future. Labaree's second category, social efficiency, is one which had not discussed at all in class. Labaree makes the claim that schools need to train students to become effective workers in the future. This approach does not focus on the needs of the individual; rather, the productivity of workers for a collectivist society. I disagree with this category because it views students as commodities rather than people. According to Labaree's idea of social efficiency, the value of people is largely connected to their economic value to their employers. Labaree's third category, social mobility, is an idea that our class strongly disagreed with. Both the class and Labaree agree that education should be a tool for improving people's economic situations, but Labaree argues that meritocracy will always be in conflict with equality. Labaree also believes that stratification is inevitable because the wealthy, suburban schools will always promote competitive students while lower income, urban schools will always have more relaxed standards. In contrast, we agreed in class that both meritocracy and equality of opportunity were possible to achieve in urban schools.
Labaree's three reasons for the existence of public schools--democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility--align with the list we made in class. But while we roughly outlined the same ideas, we didn't make the connection that these things are often at odds with one another. More importantly, Labaree comes to the conclusion that social mobility, and the inherent commodification that it brings to education, is at the root of many of our educational ills.
I'd never though of it before, but this argument makes sense. This was written in the mid-90's, before No Child Left Behind and the SOLs, but it predicts the rise of our current test-driven school environment. It also explains the observation we made in class that schools don't seem to do a very good job of training people to be citizens of a democracy.
I see parallels in the rise of social mobility as the paramount goal of public education with other public institutions in the United States. Healthcare, for example, is treated as a basic government service in most other developed countries, but in the US it's a profit driven industry that has lead to exorbitant prices and restricted access for many people. Labaree draws on Marx to explain how this commodification affects education credentials: "In a capitalist society, he argued, the market abstracts social products from their original context and particular function, reifies this abstraction by making it into a generic commodity, and makes it equivalent to all other commodities by assigning it a monetary value."
Education, as with health care and other basic services, is not a just another commodity, and when treated as such we end up with the problems we have today. But while the article does a good job of making this point, what it doesn't offer is a solution. If the social mobility rational for public school existence is at the root of our increased inequality, weak academic standards and lessened democratic participation, shouldn't we try to lessen its effects? And if so, what does that model look like?
Reflecting back on the list our class created regarding reasons for public schools, there are both consistencies and inconsistencies as to whether the items on this list can be associated with the three goals of education explored in Labaree’s article. Looking first at the goal of democratic equality, I was reminded of certain additions to our list that mentioned the concepts of informed and politically able citizens. Labaree discusses how the democratic equality goal aims to create good “Republicans”, or responsible and adept democratic participants. He also describes how one noticeable outcome of this goal is our inclusion of civics, history, and government classes in different levels of the education system. While we discussed that there is arguably not enough of an emphasis on such classes, the ideas on our list and the concepts of the democratic equality goal do match up here. Some people also emphasized the forms of equality offered by public schools, which further agrees with the egalitarian ideals of the democratic equality goal. When it comes to the goals of social efficiency and social mobility, I think our list had fewer comparable items. I don’t remember a specific example, but we did generally discuss public education as a means for advancement professionally and economically within modern American society. I however don’t think that our class would have agreed with the characteristics of the social efficiency system which result in marketplace structures being mirrored within the educational system in a way that, while encouraging education and employment, basically maintains the status quo of how far certain people are able to advance themselves. Similarly, while the class did discuss the idea of public schools providing “greater opportunities” for all students, I don’t think anyone was advocating for the “get ahead” culture of the social mobility goal. A system that mostly benefits those already at the top, especially white and upper class families, and transforms emphasis from being placed on all students to emphasis being placed on individual students doesn’t seem to agree with our class’ basic ideas of public education. The notion that degrees and grades become merely “educational credentials” to be exchanged for higher paying jobs similarly clashes with the sentiments of our list. One purpose for public schools that was mentioned on our list was but doesn’t seem to agree with any of these three goals was the purpose of “inspiration” or providing a means for personal fulfillment. Are these too idealistic as being goals in themselves? Can they be separated from the goals of citizenship and social advancement or are they inherently already included with the other three?
While looking back at the list created in class, I think Labaree's educational goals do correlate with our ideas on the purpose of public education. Labaree distinguishes the goals of education to be "democratic equality, social efficiency and social mobility." These goals, I think, have a general theme of what I call "social benefit" where, in some manner, society--as a whole--benefits from education. Even though "social mobility" is intended for individual growth, it indirectly affects the general population, where everyone is expected to "be prepared for successful social competition (p.5).
In our class discussion, we mentioned how public school is supposed to prepare students to be aware citizens. Through "democratic equality," Labaree points that public schooling was created to achieve this goal. The article also mentioned how the schools and school systems were geared to focus on equal treatment and equal access, which I remember to be a predominant element in our classroom list.
Although we did not talk about this in class, I personally believe that Labaree's final goal "social mobility" has become the norm of education today. Education has become a private good, a business, where only a few benefit from it.
The article touched on very true and current issues on public education. I wish, however, that in light of all of the problems in education, Labaree would've spent some time in researching possible solutions or strategies to better the system.
Labaree's article somewhat aligns with our class' list of reasons for having a public education. In class our reasons for a public education were condensed to knowledge empowerment, democratic citizenship, ability to have choices, and career growth. Labaree says the American Education has had three goals: democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility.
The goal of democratic equality for citizens is referred to a public good. Everyone needs to know as much as possible and education should be easily accessible to everyone in order to have a true democracy. By achieving this goal, everyone can contribute to our society as a whole. I believe this to be such an important quality for our public education to have. However, in order to contribute to our society, public education should have social mobility. Social mobility is mainly for students individually. There is opportunity for career growth such as, a salary increase. Although, as we mentioned in class, we believed knowledge empowerment to be a goal. The question comes to mind, can these two work together to help people enjoy successful and fulfilling lives? Social efficiency is Labaree's third goal. It is private training for public benefit. Everyone benefits from more skilled workers. As well as make education more responsive to career needs.
With Labaree and our class list of goals in mind, education should bring a sense of fulfillment from the moment students start to attend school to when they are ready to go out into the world. Students can see their worth and how they can not only feel empowered, but also contribute to our society.
So here is what I have gathered. Our main discussion in class held a common theme, in that the greater good for society is the most important reason for public school. Other than that, I didn’t pick up on any strong indications towards Labaree’s other two main points (social efficiency and social mobility).
Our list resonates with democratic equality the strongest. It is the model for creating the most effective citizen with relative equality across all public schools. It provides equal training, treatment, and access. Our list focused on the access and citizen training point mostly, but its only after digesting what Labaree says does it dawn on me that this is where our “standardization” comes from. After all, we are not all equal; we are each blessed with our own advantages and disadvantages.
I get the feeling that social mobility is painted as an evil to the “public good”, but I differ on this opinion. Social mobility is the drive of the individual to gain all that they can from the education system. However, it does not serve only the individual, but it can be used for the greater public good. It creates competition; driving force for innovation that benefits us all.
But I find social efficiency the most interesting to think about, only because its future in its current form is not certain. For instance, look at the pace of technology; we have the birthing of artificial intelligence, self driving vehicles, and cold brew coffee. The number one occupation for working men in America (truck driver) is on its way out thanks to trucks that can drive themselves. Before, whenever technology made some factory jobs obsolete, more jobs were created in its place. However, as we move further into the future, we may not have anything to replace them with.
If the pull of social efficiency weakens, what will happen to the justification of public education for the public good of our workforce? How will our education system balance itself? I have no answers for these questions, but it’s fun to entertain the them.
I love your perspective on his discussion regarding social efficiency. I never thought about social efficiency in the way that you have presented it, but it's such a valid thought process. I wonder if we are moving away from social efficiency more towards social mobility simply on the premise of uncertainty in job offerings that you mention.
I also like that you are honest about your difference in opinion around social mobility. I believe that social mobility, in modern society, is becoming a more negative aspect because of how some are not included simply on resources that they may have or not have. However, it's important to keep in mind that despite these negatives, there are positives to social mobility. For some, this is the inspiration that keeps students persisting despite the struggles they may face.
In the article by Labaree the three reasons that he lists for why schools should exist or be used consist of either democratic equality where he talks about this focusing on preparing citizens; social efficiency which focuses on training workers or social mobility, which, prepares individuals for social positions.
As a class unit we agreed that school is in place to help us to get a career to make money, it is there for knowledge and empowerment and knowledge being a source of power by which we can get other things accomplished and we saw school as a means of creating citizens to live in the world and change it.
I think that looking at these two lists they are very similar in nature. We as a class agreed that in some shape, the democracy of the world, where we create citizens is important just as Labaree had thought. In conjunction with this, I think that as a unit this should be focused on. We should be prepping the next generation to be people. I don't think that Labaree left anything out because these three goals of schools that he had are such large umbrellas that other things could fit underneath it. Although we as a class came up with a group list, in individual group settings there were other things that were stated that might not be mentioned such as the opportunity for growth in addition to the opportunity to feel loved and have that need be fulfilled by teachers. I also think that these could go under one of the umbrella terms that Labaree suggests as being a goal for schools.
Other thoughts that I had were that the breakdown of each of the goals of school that Labaree had were broken down in a nice way. Also, I liked how they all fit into each other. There was a way that democratic equality went with social mobility or that social mobility intertwined with social efficiency. The goal and overall motive of school is inefficient without another part.
There were plenty of points made in the article which we mentioned in our class discussion, and how they intersect with history. The purposes of education, as found in Labaree's article, discuss how it prepares students for work life/getting them ready for labor and taking direction, preparing members of a democratic system, and preparing them to compete in social situations (Work). In class, we did not really mention competition, and were focused more on self fulfillment, and how realization and independence can build confidence in our citizens, therefore having contributing members. In the three points that we came up with during class, we were able to recognize how the education system is failing in each purpose. Labaree calls this an adaption to inequality, which is true when we take our time contemplating issues and not taking action. The article also discusses the the conflict that occurs when trying to satisfy all these purposes, and how they can often contradict each other. This is something we talked about in class, especially when we mentioned the politics, under the new administration.
When comparing Labaree’s list for having public schools (democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility), it’s clear that it begins to mirror the list that we created in class. However, he goes on to discuss how this list is implemented depending on who is benefiting from education. In a perfect world, we would all benefit from education (and in some ways, we do), but I think it’s important to think about how this benefit is different dependent on the stakeholder. I enjoyed reading the different perspectives as I hadn’t thought about that when making our list in class. From a teacher’s perspective, I believe we often focus on his version of democratic equality. Despite a big push to “teach to the test”, we want our students to be quality members of society and to feel as if they have a voice.
I found it incredibly interesting that Labaree stressed how focusing on one goal can often be at the expense of another. On the surface, it seems as if all of these three goals mesh together. If we are teaching our students to be great citizens and instilling a hard work ethic in them, they should easily be able to get a job and move up the social ladder, right? Well, we all know that it doesn’t work that way. It’s not that simple and that only some people benefit from education in that manner. When you dig deeper into these goals, primarily by looking at the stakeholder or beneficiary of the goal, one can find conflict. And this conflict makes sense. It’s clear that some goals are the current primary focus of education and explains why there are such disparities in the quality of education a child can receive. Additionally, I believe this conflict may play a role into teacher turnover- teachers who are asked to implement all three goals, but are truly only evaluated on one. They may have successfully implemented all three goals, but when a district is only looking at one, that superb teacher then looks average. While this conflict is not the only accounting factor of both quality of education and teacher turnaround, it allows for an interesting perspective of education. Labaree challenges his readers to think about the purpose of education much like we did in class. It is easy to begin listing the purposes of education, but harder to start specifically listing these reasons and begin relating them to one another. As teachers, I think most of us wish for a just education system, but what does that include? Is it enough to have public education that benefits one party the most (and often isn’t necessarily the direct consumer of education-the student)? I think this is a hard question to answer. The solution to better education undoubtedly lies in all three goals, which is why it’s so hard to find an effective solution. With this being said, I agree with Labaree that society is pushing towards promoting mainly the social mobility goal. The only problem with this is that it’s not really promoting social mobility for all- just the ones who have access, as he mentions with the importance of reputation, grades, and social competition.
The only aspect of Labaree’s article that wasn’t portrayed in our list was the sense of empowerment. He discussed the idea of using knowledge as a means to make money, to have security, or to set oneself apart from the crowd, but not as a way to feel empowered, to feel inspired. Education shouldn’t be a one-trick show. It should be giving students the opportunity to better their lives, but also the sense that they are in control, not society. Right now, society, for many, is in control. I’m looking forward to learning more about the possible solutions to these issues and how we can effectively implement all three of these goals to ensure that every child is receiving a purposeful, empowering, and just education.
Labaree's article aligns with three of the points from our list, but does not address empowerment through knowledge, as we discussed in class. The history of Labaree's three purposes for schools is beneficial and in a way crucial to understanding the three purposes themselves, and I found it interesting to read about historically why these purposes are so important. We didn't go much further after identifying the purposes of education we found important, and it would have taken much longer to go further beneath the surface, but Labaree does with subcategories for each purpose. For Democratic Equality, he goes further to into citizenship training, equal treatment, and equal access, which were all points that were brought up during our brainstorming before identifying the main purposes. When Labaree discusses social mobility, he highlights that students quickly replace the understanding that knowledge is important, with he understanding that its credentials (grades, etc.) that get them where they want to be. He explains that the value of knowledge is in turn the value of grades or credentials and eventually money. This understanding is what motivates students toward success. Our discussion in class did not seem to get to this point, but I feel Labaree touches on many topics below the surface of our discussion, that is based on the same purposes for education. As others have said, the purposes align to the purposes we listed in class, but Labaree goes a little deeper into each purpose, and does not discuss the sense of empowerment, but rather discusses the motivation for competition, money, and credentials to succeed in life.
I believe that the list has a lot of similarities and very few differences with Labaree's article. Labaree says that American education has three goals: democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility. These three goals directly relate to our list. We discussed how schools should focus on preparing citizens (democratic equality), focus on training workers (social efficiency), and preparing individuals to compete for social positions (social mobility).
In addition, Labaree talks a lot about how politics and political views have a strong effect on how we perceive schools and how schools and school issues should be handled. This idea and thought was something that we listed in class as well. Personally, I believe it goes deeper, "What are your morals? How do you decipher what is right or wrong? What influences your beliefs about education?" I believe that politics may play a huge role but beliefs play a more significant role because beliefs shape your political ideology. Labaree touched on this topic, starting on page 71, when he started to discuss credentialism. The theme of humility and pride both resonated with me when I read this. On one hand, you are humble about your credentials so you very rarely discuss them. Then on the other hand you worked hard for your credentials so you should be proud and not devalued. This is directly related to morality and values because humility and pride ultimately stems from what you believe in.
As I said previously, Labaree took a more political approach to this topic. I believe that this was a great approach because it showed how politics are heavily involved in the education world. In contrast, I believe that he did leave out the more "ethical" side of this subject. As we discussed in the class, power equals money when it comes to society's outlook of power and influence. This subject lead us in the discussion of how teachers have to teach for career building in order for students to build that money, and to teach for students to be culturally knowledgeable and want change. We said that we need to teach the students that the more money you have, the more lives you can impact, especially/specifically those who are in the same situation that you once were in. Also, we need to teach these two subjects together because a strong career with financial stability is pointless without helping others (which goes back morality and values).
Labaree identified three reasons to why public schools exist, which were similar to the ones we, as a class, identified on Tuesday. He stated the three principal reasons were social mobility, social efficiency, and democratic equality. However, Labaree left out the idea of public schools as a source for empowerment. Although social mobility or democratic equality is somewhat similar to empowerment, Labaree stressed social mobility as a “private good.” Opposed to empowerment, social mobility allows individuals to build credentials through public schooling, resulting in an ability to move up or stay in the current socio-economic status. Labaree, additionally, highlighted how each of these three principals often clashes with each other. I found his portrayal of these principals as often being in conflict extremely interesting. Although, Labaree points out social mobility can bring about democratic equality or vice versa, his argument stressed the differences between each principal. In contrast, I think social mobility, democratic equality, and social efficiency can be achieved cooperatively. For example, I think RTR is an example of both a social mobility and efficiency-based program. We, as RTR students, achieve a vocational training as teachers in graduate school (efficiency-based), while also gaining more educational credentials, through a master’s degree (mobility-based). In addition, the program focuses on training teachers, who “check their privilege at the door” to provide equal treatment of future students. After all, this is a class that familiarizes us with the ethics of teaching. Although, Labaree stated schools should and can balance these three principals but the tasks remains hard in practice, when so many interests pull education from one principal to another. I disagreed with his notion that social mobility cannot achieve community uplift. As mentioned above, Labaree characterized social mobility as a “private good” versus a “public good”, like democratic equality or social efficiency-based education. I think community uplift can be achieved through the individual opposed to strictly being based on community engagement. However, Labaree made an excellent point in emphasizing how social mobility essentially curtails education to a pyramid hierarchical structure, with a top-down order. Labaree excellently displayed how performance-based curriculum standards have pushed education towards social mobility, where the primary concern is passing tests to achieve grades and credentials. Furthermore, I agree with Labaree that education has become very “meritocratic,” just like the corporate world, where learning and becoming engaged in the material is becoming less important.
Labaree’s three categories are democratic equality, social efficiency, or social mobility. The list in class that we created included: equal opportunity, access to careers, knowledge empowerment, chance to choose, and democratic citizenship. I don’t think any of the three categories really touch on knowledge for empowerment, however I don’t think knowledge for empowerment has to be an exclusive reasons for public education. I believe that all three categories hit on equal opportunity in theory but Labaree does a good job at explaining that the hopes for public education are different than the reality. Democratic citizenship matches with democratic equality however Labaree highlights the idea of shaping political leaders than total citizenship which I think includes voting, understanding democracy, and being involved in more ways that just running for office (such as being an informed citizen about what is happening in your community). Access to careers matches with social efficiency however in the article it focuses on the idea that taxpayers/ business owners want public education for trained individuals to work for them. Chance to choose and social mobility loosely tie into each other, for Labaree social mobility is part of private free markets that are trying to create competition in market roles. I don’t think in class we really talked about the privation of education since we focused on what public education should do. Labree argues the biggest threat to public education in having social mobility be the guiding goal of education which further moves education into a private good. One of the political problems in education in balancing “freedom” and “inequalities. Labree uses an example of Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamlinton’s competing economic views. Hamilton believes that total capitalism and economic freedom leads to a highly unequal distribution of wealth and power however Jefferson argues restricting economic freedom to address inequality infringes on individual liberty which is dangerous to sustaining a democracy. In Labree article it seems like democratic equality would be the model that would want public education to emphasis knowledge for empowerment and but would not address inequalities and inequities.
In class I remember there being a focus on the advancement of society and the creation of opportunity as some of the main purposes of public education. Labaree touches on those points more deeply with his three reasons for public education, democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility. Like in our class the purpose of the advancement of society fell into the democratic equality category and the choice of opportunity fell into the social mobility argument. However, I would argue that while social mobility may provide choices and opportunities for some, those choices are restricted by class, gender and race as opposed to "individual achievement," as argued by Labaree. (60) I do agree that social mobility is a result of a culture of individualism that is perpetuated through the commodification of education.
I think that the consumerism and individualism of American culture continues to place more value on the worth of education in terms of wealth and social mobility.These value systems are perpetuated by politicians who are elected and create policies that perpetuate consumerism, simply because it directly benefits them, but also they keep getting elected. Labaree argued, politics is the problem with our education system. (40) The constant political fighting over the purpose of education by progressives and conservatives has led to a stagnation in vision and has let the the contradictions and cross purposes muddle the goals of education.( 71) With our current political climate, it has become more important to attempt to influence education locally since the federal level of policy making has become so divisive.
If our values as a society remain focused on individualism, consumerism, and divisiveness, then our schools will continue to be spaces focused on meritocracy that perpetuate the advancement of those who have access to resources and skills that determine who is socially mobile via education. Our values in our society are reflected in our politicians who are elected then perpetuate policies that promote a more limited sense of social mobility as a purpose for education. Labaree showed that the purpose of education had been swayed more heavily by his three purposes at different times historically depending on the national political consciousness. I agree, that in order for education to have a clear vision that promotes social advancement in terms of creating good citizens and providing choices, American cultural values need to drive the national political discourse to create policies that will drive those purposes. In my opinion, education is a symptom of a larger systemic cultural and political problem which values the worth of wealth more than civic democratic society. That is why as teachers we need to promote the cultural change from within our classrooms that will one day lead to political change. Labaree was very poignant to quote Horace Mann, "...private fortunes are among the greatest dangers to which the happiness of the people of the republic can be subjected."(45) -Nick Bergheimer
We stated that public education should create equal opportunity, career advancement, the chance to choose, empowerment through knowledge, and strengthened democratic citizenship. David Labaree focuses on democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility as the three often conflicting goals of education. Many connections between lists were present, while a noticeable difference in who these goals are working to benefit was presented by Labaree. Democratic equality as described by Labaree (1997) is fairly similar to our comments on the topic of democratic citizenship; in the view of all students as citizens, there is equality and school is a way to strengthen this equal political competence (p. 42). Our comments in class focused on the need (and current lack) for students to leave school with an informed place in democracy; both our class and Labaree agree that this informed democracy can be attained through the creation of a similar knowledge base (starting with similar classes in schools). Our thoughts on democratic equality as a class aligned with Labaree mostly because we acknowledged that every student has access to this. Social efficiency is closely related to our class topic of career advancement, although as a class we didn’t discuss the logistics of this idea. Labaree discusses that social efficiency relies on the idea that productivity within the occupational marketplace is for everyone, and that school should be focusing on jobs instead of any similar base knowledge for students. While this idea of everyone going to school for a place in the occupational market seems as if it would create equality, Labaree also states that diplomas from different high schools and colleges do not allow for these students to receive the same occupations. As a class, we discussed careers and the chance to choose as being available to everyone who receives an education (ideally), and Labaree approaches this idea of efficiency with the same hesitance. Lastly, social mobility relates to our class idea of having the choice to choose, although this goal views school as a private good in Labaree’s article. In social mobility, education is seen as a commodity that puts certain consumers at an advantage in social situations. Education is no longer collective under the lens of social mobility; this goal of education focuses on the individual and what opportunities they alone can receive from schools. Labaree explains this goal by discussing that the elite are able to best receive social mobility by purchasing the goods needed (a house in the right district, a degree from an Ivy League institution, etc.). Inequality has a large place in social mobility; inequality was something that we discussed directly in the topic of a chance to choose, but one that I believe was silently agreed upon. Our class list coincides with Labaree’s to an extent, but there are differences in their viewpoints and those who benefit. We discussed our list in the context of everyone who receives public education; every student should receive equal opportunity, career advancement, the viewpoint of knowledge as power, the chance to choose, and democratic citizenship. As many previous classmates have commented, Labaree argues that many of the categories he presented (democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility) often work against each other; while democratic equality and social efficiency can work to benefit everyone, social mobility only works for a select few. Had we spent time talking about the realistic expectations versus reality of these goals of education, I believe that we would have come to many of the same conclusions about inequality and personal gain as Labaree. A difference between lists was the idea that knowledge as power doesn’t fit into one of the three categories presented by Labaree; this could be its own goal for public education with its benefits and implications. Overall, I feel as if there were many connections between our goals and those of Labaree.
In class, we discussed many of the ideas that Labaree addresses such as the goal of education to develop democratic citizens, breed contributing members to the workforce, and provide equal opportunities. However, we didn’t talk about how some of these can come into conflict with one another. Labaree discusses the difficulty in finding a balance among the goals for education and who benefits from them.
We collectively prioritized equal access to opportunities and addressed the merits of producing contributing working members of society without diving into possible contradictions these might pose. Social efficiency “promotes the sorting of students” which “leads to the limitation of opportunities for these students” going against one of the goals on our class list (Labaree, 1997, pg 50). Labaree pointed out preparing people for the workforce or to be contributing members of society can contradict the goal of providing equal opportunities. While democratic equality and social efficiency feed back and support the society, social mobility looks at education as a more private or personal acquisition.
I thought it was interesting that Labaree referred to democratic equality and social efficiency as a public good and social mobility as a private good. I haven’t thought about the goals of education in these terms, but that is very much what drives society views and support or lack of support of schools and education. As Labaree states, society lacks “public love” without payment when looking at education (pg 62). There isn’t support for providing and nurturing each child as an individual but rather there is a focus on producing members that help support and benefit the society. While I (along with the class as shown in our collective list) think all of these goals are important in education, I relate to this last goal the most as a driving force in my own aspiration to teach these children.
I think Labaree explained the possible benefits and negatives to each of the goals for education and where they each might cause dissonance for one another. It would have been beneficial to have examples of possible propositions for how to meld these goals which seemed to be lacking.
I believe that while the language used was slightly different, the ideals for public education that we came up with in class were the same that were found in the Labaree article. He articulates democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility as the primary reasons for education, while we said democratic citizenship, having a career and making money, and empowerment were the primary reasons. Stripping these terms down from particular nuances the meaning is the same across the three broad categories.
The democratic piece is essential because of the political system that our students live in, and in which they will (hopefully) participate as adults. So, schools should teach children in a way to make them informed citizens that will be able to analyze issues and be politically active, as well as instill morals and insights into what is right so that they will make good choices. I find this goal slightly ironic, considering that the only time we teach civics, politics, or government to student is briefly in elementary school, in 8th grade, and in the 12th grade. Just speaking from personal experience, most people know very little about their government and the way it functions. Social efficiency is basically the socialization of children to be productive members of society, and the way that that is usually described is by getting a job so you can be useful and engage with society and help it run smoothly, rather than being unemployed or homeless (which are seen from a societal view as negative). I say that social mobility and empowerment are extremely similar because they have similar goals. Those who generally strive for greater mobility are those who live at the bottom of the social hierarchy, and the best way to achieve this mobility is through empowerment (and reparations, although that’s another story).
Just as a side note, I found it surprising that in none of Labaree’s categories or in our discussion did the reason of self-fulfillment or a sort of “species being” (from Karl Marx) come up. This refers to reaching a person’s own utmost potential and creating an environment in which they can be the best they can be at whatever they choose to be. This is always what I’d sort of believed education should be, and I think that the other categories we developed could even fit inside of it. To build people up to reach their full potential they will become better democratic citizens, they will have a meaningful career, they would be empowered, as well as reaching a certain level of personal happiness, which I like to think is also a goal we should have for our children.
I agree with you about self-fulfillment, as I think most of our class mates would, but I think the hard part is how to actually implement this. I think Montessori schools, with their emphasis on children following their own interests, might be a model for public schools to emulate.
Labaree discusses the three “alternative goals” of education as democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility. He goes even further to label each as either a public or private good and explains that each goal comes from a specific perspective, that of a citizen, a taxpayer, or a consumer. His goals closely resemble the list we generated as a class, despite a difference in language.
While Labaree discusses social efficiency, we termed it “career”, referring to career identification, development, and training. I agree with Labaree that this particular goal comes from the employer, and taxpayers, who demand prepared and trained workers to fill prescribed roles. This is perhaps the most obvious goal of public education, made evident by the educational requirements listed at every job posting. While some roles may require a specific degree or training, others specify a GED or high school diploma, and nearly all mandate that the worker be able to read and write.
Labaree also describes social mobility as a goal, which he views as a competition between students for “desirable social positions”. This definition loosely translates to our discussion of the “chance to choose” in life and has the same underlying reasoning, albeit different ultimate purposes. Labaree describes social mobility from the perspective of the consumer, labeling it a private good used to obtain a competitive edge over other consumers. Our own discussion was far more altruistic. We focused on the idea of opportunity to choose as a deeply personal goal without a purpose in a competitive job market. The idea of choice is more akin to freedom than to a social competition.
On the third goal of education, democratic equality, our class was in complete agreement with Labaree. From the perspective of a citizen, education’s purpose is to create responsible and competent citizens who are capable of participating in our society. This is certainly a public good as it specifically serves society as a whole.
As a future educator, the most important goal I have for public education is to build knowledge and empower students. Labaree fails to mention the idea of building knowledge as a specific goal of education, possibly because it loosely falls into the idea of social efficiency in the form of preparation and training. I would argue that building knowledge is its own separate goal and requires particular attention and effort. An interest in knowledge and a feeling of empowerment is the foundation on which the other three goals stand, for without them a student will have no interest in career, competing, or the society around them.
We discussed in class that public education should provide: equal opportunity, career preparation, individual empowerment, choice, and promote democratic citizenship. Labaree describes his three goals of education: preparing democratic citizens, promoting social efficiency, and promoting social mobility. He correlates each to a citizen's goal, a taxpayer's goal, and a consumer's goal, respectively. In all, I think that we as a class touched on most of the ideas Labaree presented in a more broad way. Some of our class points overlap with Labaree's goals. For instance, choice and individual empowerment can be lumped into Labaree's social mobility goal. In this goal, the consumer seeks the best education for personal benefit regardless of the need of the community, economy, or political environment. Labaree's social efficiency goal matches with our class goal of career preparation. In this case, the taxpayer dictates what the economy needs and therefore what the education system should promote and encourage. Finally, both our class and Labaree agree that a goal of education systems should be to prepare democratic citizens. While Labaree states throughout that our society has shied away from emphasizing this goal as our country has grown, I still think this goal should be an important cornerstone in education. It seemed that both mobility and efficiency could include promoting and creating good, well educated "republicans." The challenges Labaree discusses towards the end of his essay outline what I hope to gain through thoughtful discussion today with the class. I found myself going back and forth as to which goal I supported. It is a tough problem to solve, yet the fundamental foundation of democracy is compromise and that our society's ebb and flow should allow for success at all levels of education.
Similar to Labree’s list we made a big point of focusing on our public schools use as a resource for educating and creating citizens prepared to live in a democracy is spot on with Labree’s first goal of public education. Our other two points where either symptoms or consequences of his other two goals of american education.
He cites Gutmann and Hirsch’s statement that our public education should prepare citizens “to participate intelligently as adults in the political process that shapes their society.” This notion is the very essence of having an equal and just government, a government of the people, by the people, for the people. Now, is this always the case of public school systems? No. As he asserts in section on social mobility, their will always be disparities. As is the nature of a capitalist society, people are always seeking the best for themselves or their children, to gain that edge over someone else. The very notion that someone would want to move their child to a better school means somebody else would be left with the lesser option and impede on their social mobility. Our idea of schools as a tool for social efficiency, while thoughtful in theory, has also impeded students social mobility. The inherent differences in the education that comes along with sorting students into different levels of education is flawed. While they may be receiving an education that challenges them in the classroom it may not necessarily reflect on standardized scores in turn affecting their social mobility. Our social mobility and efficiency have a large impact on our security as person. They directly impact what opportunities we have access to and where we end up in our lives. If looked at as having three major functions, at our point in time now, society has chosen to focus on the social mobility branch more so than the other two. Currently placing more emphasis on prestige than an equitable and quality education.
How knew, the list from Labaree and the list we listed in class are very similar. Our list was more about equity and equal opportunities, empowerment, democratic citizenship, and chose to chose. Similarly, Labaree stated that democratic equality; schools shuld focus on preparing citizens, social mobility; school should prepare individuals to compete for social positions, and social efficiency; school should focus on training workers.
Labaree goes on and talks about each of the educational goal. What I walk away from this article is there are just so much people want public school ( teachers, us), to do and there is a very little supports we got. In addition, each goal is opposite to one another, public good and private good.
It is sad that we are one nation, under God, but we have opposite view. While taxpayer and citizen want to educate an over all people equally and fair, the consumer said that we should not do that because people who work hard for it deserve better. In away, education system or level attainment place people in different class. It become a part of the game where people who are ahead gets all and make sure people behind will not catch up them easily.
One thing I notice missing from this article was morality. This might sound like religious thing but it is not. It common sense and it vital in our society. While we are so busy teaching our children about everything, SOL, or pursuing educational goal, we forgot to teach our next generation of our children to be good people. People with common sense, nice, understanding. I believe if we the people, from the most powerful citizen in our capital to the homeless citizen on street, have good in ourselves, we will be in a much better place.
I completely agree with you Asein! The author list one view and fails to look at it from any other; which is what others do as well. He focused on his thoughts and what schools should focus and not on what they’re doing in comparison. As discussed in class, we described public education as valuable and something that all people should have the access to with the proper resources. I did notice that time and time again education is looked at from a capitalist view point. I believe this hinders the school system resulting negatively for the students. Students start to learn just to earn any job, or for the credentials and not for the excitement of the knowledge. Many teachers struggle to motivate their students and often feel it is not their duty, but in order to help these students grow we need to. I’ve heard one of the most intelligent students say they’ll be a mechanic just because their father is. To me, that sounds like no one motivated them to be the best they could be. If it is not being done at home, then school has to be that place where they can be encouraged to be all that they can. Teaching is more than academics and that’s what politics fail to realize.
Isn't motivation to be the best you can be part of the Social Mobility goal? That is, isn't it in the consumer's or individual's interest to be the best they can be? Maybe in the social mobility arena, the individual must be self-motivated. That may be the fundamental idea of this goal. It's not in the best interest of the employer for the individual to be the best person, just the best employee. Likewise, a citizen is more concerned at the student becoming a good citizen.
Katie S. Labaree breaks down the overall goals and views of education into three categories, all of which we touched on one way or another in class. In our class list, we included education as a means for empowering citizens to become involved in democracy, as a way to equip people with practical skills that can make them valuable members of the work force, which in turn can help give people more social and economic mobility. We included a few more goals of public education, but overall, our list relates to Larabee's.
Larabee goes further in breaking these goals down into two categories: public good and private good. He sees democratic equality and social efficiency (training workers) as public goods, and social mobility as a private good. I agree with his assessment that our educational system has suffered due to conflict between these conflicting categories. However, I'm not certain I entirely agree with his claim that the focus of our educational system has shifted towards a consumer perspective. He says that now, the focus is on the pursuit of credentials rather than knowledge. As far as our culture's approach to higher education, I agree with his sentiment. But when it comes to grade school, especially in the earlier years, I don't know that the focus has skewed quite as much.
Although our class list compares pretty well to Labaree's list, it seemed that ours focused pretty heavily on democratic equality. We felt that ideally, education should empower people, especially by giving people equal treatment and equal access to quality education at any level.
Labaree gave perspective to the issue of school reform that I had not ever considered. His three reasons for schools; democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility, were all represented in our lists. I knew schools were often plagued by politics, Labaree's breakdown of the competing interests gave me a greater understanding of the issues we see in school reform. While there is overlap, these interests do contradict one another. Americans seem remiss to admit its true reasons for public education, but maybe we just don't know. As Labaree stated "As a resultof being forcedto muddleits goals and continually work at cross-purposes, education inevitably turns out to be deficient in carrying out any of these goals very effectively." I agree with Labaree that America should narrow its goals.We should continue to fight the structures that minoritize groups, so that social mobility is possible for those who seek it regardless of race, gender, religion and other factors. Yet, a focus on assuming rights and responsibilities as a citizen and intrinsic achievements rather than status might lead to a better functioning society and take the politics out of our schools. In our uncertain times, there is the possibility for change. We can redefine success in America, starting with our schools.
Laubree has three categories that he discusses: democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility. Democratic equality is teaching the youth to be productive citizens so that we may trust in their future decisions to lead us. Social efficiency says that how well we are doing economically directly effects our ability to prepare the youth. Social mobility is the theory that school is designed to create an advantage for our students in the competition for good market roles.
During our last class, we discussed a variety of reasons for public school. One that was common among us and stuck out was equality. Laubree suggests that to achieve equality, schools must focus on building citizenship and relative equality. The list we designed in class does closely align with his three categories, but there are some things left out.
Like Katie said, there was nothing discussed about empowerment through knowledge. We had a long discussion about this in class and I feel that it is one of the most important aspects of education. While this article focuses on more of the political side of education, I firmly believe that the ethical side is just as important. Empowerment through knowledge will allow our students to go far in life in whatever they choose to do. In class, we talked about how knowledge can allow our students to not be take advantage of. The more knowledge they have, the better their understanding, and the further they can go. We also discussed that through this, the students have a better understanding of themselves and are less likely to be molded into what society says they are.
Another thought I had while reading this article is that on page 40, he discusses the changes that could be made within schools. He mentions Black academies as one. In TEDU 626 we recently discussed race in schools. It is inevitable that by being in this program, all of us will be teaching at predominantly black schools. Keeping in mind that to some of us, this culture is different. I think it speaks volumes that some people believe creating all black academies could benefit education. A lot of times, young teachers go into the schools wanting to change these children. Having a point of reference to understand this culture, instead of wanting to “fix” it can make all the difference.
Tues. June 13 - If you were asked, as a teacher, to provide a comment to the local newspaper about a contemporary issue facing public education, what would you share and why?
Thurs. June 8 - Do you think that it is the teacher's role to overtly work to make the world a better place? What are some things that you could/will try to do as an educator to work toward social improvement/justice? Be as specific as possible.
Although Labaree does touch on some of our class list of reasons for having public schools, he leaves out most of the points we emphasized in class. Labaree's first category, which he calls democratic equality, is an idea he shares with our class list. The main point of the idea is that political competence is necessary in democratic societies and one of the many goals of public schools is to promote values that create good citizens. An aspect of democratic equality that Labaree leaves out is the importance of equal opportunities. Labaree highlights political equality, specifically one person, one vote, but he neglects to mention the lack of equality in level of education and prospects for the future.
ReplyDeleteLabaree's second category, social efficiency, is one which had not discussed at all in class. Labaree makes the claim that schools need to train students to become effective workers in the future. This approach does not focus on the needs of the individual; rather, the productivity of workers for a collectivist society. I disagree with this category because it views students as commodities rather than people. According to Labaree's idea of social efficiency, the value of people is largely connected to their economic value to their employers.
Labaree's third category, social mobility, is an idea that our class strongly disagreed with. Both the class and Labaree agree that education should be a tool for improving people's economic situations, but Labaree argues that meritocracy will always be in conflict with equality. Labaree also believes that stratification is inevitable because the wealthy, suburban schools will always promote competitive students while lower income, urban schools will always have more relaxed standards. In contrast, we agreed in class that both meritocracy and equality of opportunity were possible to achieve in urban schools.
Labaree's three reasons for the existence of public schools--democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility--align with the list we made in class. But while we roughly outlined the same ideas, we didn't make the connection that these things are often at odds with one another. More importantly, Labaree comes to the conclusion that social mobility, and the inherent commodification that it brings to education, is at the root of many of our educational ills.
ReplyDeleteI'd never though of it before, but this argument makes sense. This was written in the mid-90's, before No Child Left Behind and the SOLs, but it predicts the rise of our current test-driven school environment. It also explains the observation we made in class that schools don't seem to do a very good job of training people to be citizens of a democracy.
I see parallels in the rise of social mobility as the paramount goal of public education with other public institutions in the United States. Healthcare, for example, is treated as a basic government service in most other developed countries, but in the US it's a profit driven industry that has lead to exorbitant prices and restricted access for many people. Labaree draws on Marx to explain how this commodification affects education credentials: "In a capitalist society, he argued, the market abstracts social products from their original context and particular function, reifies this abstraction by making it into a generic commodity, and makes it equivalent to all other commodities by assigning it a monetary value."
Education, as with health care and other basic services, is not a just another commodity, and when treated as such we end up with the problems we have today. But while the article does a good job of making this point, what it doesn't offer is a solution. If the social mobility rational for public school existence is at the root of our increased inequality, weak academic standards and lessened democratic participation, shouldn't we try to lessen its effects? And if so, what does that model look like?
Reflecting back on the list our class created regarding reasons for public schools, there are both consistencies and inconsistencies as to whether the items on this list can be associated with the three goals of education explored in Labaree’s article.
ReplyDeleteLooking first at the goal of democratic equality, I was reminded of certain additions to our list that mentioned the concepts of informed and politically able citizens. Labaree discusses how the democratic equality goal aims to create good “Republicans”, or responsible and adept democratic participants. He also describes how one noticeable outcome of this goal is our inclusion of civics, history, and government classes in different levels of the education system. While we discussed that there is arguably not enough of an emphasis on such classes, the ideas on our list and the concepts of the democratic equality goal do match up here. Some people also emphasized the forms of equality offered by public schools, which further agrees with the egalitarian ideals of the democratic equality goal.
When it comes to the goals of social efficiency and social mobility, I think our list had fewer comparable items. I don’t remember a specific example, but we did generally discuss public education as a means for advancement professionally and economically within modern American society. I however don’t think that our class would have agreed with the characteristics of the social efficiency system which result in marketplace structures being mirrored within the educational system in a way that, while encouraging education and employment, basically maintains the status quo of how far certain people are able to advance themselves. Similarly, while the class did discuss the idea of public schools providing “greater opportunities” for all students, I don’t think anyone was advocating for the “get ahead” culture of the social mobility goal. A system that mostly benefits those already at the top, especially white and upper class families, and transforms emphasis from being placed on all students to emphasis being placed on individual students doesn’t seem to agree with our class’ basic ideas of public education. The notion that degrees and grades become merely “educational credentials” to be exchanged for higher paying jobs similarly clashes with the sentiments of our list.
One purpose for public schools that was mentioned on our list was but doesn’t seem to agree with any of these three goals was the purpose of “inspiration” or providing a means for personal fulfillment. Are these too idealistic as being goals in themselves? Can they be separated from the goals of citizenship and social advancement or are they inherently already included with the other three?
Landon
While looking back at the list created in class, I think Labaree's educational goals do correlate with our ideas on the purpose of public education. Labaree distinguishes the goals of education to be "democratic equality, social efficiency and social mobility." These goals, I think, have a general theme of what I call "social benefit" where, in some manner, society--as a whole--benefits from education. Even though "social mobility" is intended for individual growth, it indirectly affects the general population, where everyone is expected to "be prepared for successful social competition (p.5).
ReplyDeleteIn our class discussion, we mentioned how public school is supposed to prepare students to be aware citizens. Through "democratic equality," Labaree points that public schooling was created to achieve this goal. The article also mentioned how the schools and school systems were geared to focus on equal treatment and equal access, which I remember to be a predominant element in our classroom list.
Although we did not talk about this in class, I personally believe that Labaree's final goal "social mobility" has become the norm of education today. Education has become a private good, a business, where only a few benefit from it.
The article touched on very true and current issues on public education. I wish, however, that in light of all of the problems in education, Labaree would've spent some time in researching possible solutions or strategies to better the system.
-Jayne
Labaree's article somewhat aligns with our class' list of reasons for having a public education. In class our reasons for a public education were condensed to knowledge empowerment, democratic citizenship, ability to have choices, and career growth. Labaree says the American Education has had three goals: democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility.
ReplyDeleteThe goal of democratic equality for citizens is referred to a public good. Everyone needs to know as much as possible and education should be easily accessible to everyone in order to have a true democracy. By achieving this goal, everyone can contribute to our society as a whole. I believe this to be such an important quality for our public education to have. However, in order to contribute to our society, public education should have social mobility. Social mobility is mainly for students individually. There is opportunity for career growth such as, a salary increase. Although, as we mentioned in class, we believed knowledge empowerment to be a goal. The question comes to mind, can these two work together to help people enjoy successful and fulfilling lives? Social efficiency is Labaree's third goal. It is private training for public benefit. Everyone benefits from more skilled workers. As well as make education more responsive to career needs.
With Labaree and our class list of goals in mind, education should bring a sense of fulfillment from the moment students start to attend school to when they are ready to go out into the world. Students can see their worth and how they can not only feel empowered, but also contribute to our society.
Sydney
So here is what I have gathered. Our main discussion in class held a common theme, in that the greater good for society is the most important reason for public school. Other than that, I didn’t pick up on any strong indications towards Labaree’s other two main points (social efficiency and social mobility).
ReplyDeleteOur list resonates with democratic equality the strongest. It is the model for creating the most effective citizen with relative equality across all public schools. It provides equal training, treatment, and access. Our list focused on the access and citizen training point mostly, but its only after digesting what Labaree says does it dawn on me that this is where our “standardization” comes from. After all, we are not all equal; we are each blessed with our own advantages and disadvantages.
I get the feeling that social mobility is painted as an evil to the “public good”, but I differ on this opinion. Social mobility is the drive of the individual to gain all that they can from the education system. However, it does not serve only the individual, but it can be used for the greater public good. It creates competition; driving force for innovation that benefits us all.
But I find social efficiency the most interesting to think about, only because its future in its current form is not certain. For instance, look at the pace of technology; we have the birthing of artificial intelligence, self driving vehicles, and cold brew coffee. The number one occupation for working men in America (truck driver) is on its way out thanks to trucks that can drive themselves. Before, whenever technology made some factory jobs obsolete, more jobs were created in its place. However, as we move further into the future, we may not have anything to replace them with.
If the pull of social efficiency weakens, what will happen to the justification of public education for the public good of our workforce? How will our education system balance itself? I have no answers for these questions, but it’s fun to entertain the them.
Kieran
I love your perspective on his discussion regarding social efficiency. I never thought about social efficiency in the way that you have presented it, but it's such a valid thought process. I wonder if we are moving away from social efficiency more towards social mobility simply on the premise of uncertainty in job offerings that you mention.
DeleteI also like that you are honest about your difference in opinion around social mobility. I believe that social mobility, in modern society, is becoming a more negative aspect because of how some are not included simply on resources that they may have or not have. However, it's important to keep in mind that despite these negatives, there are positives to social mobility. For some, this is the inspiration that keeps students persisting despite the struggles they may face.
Great post!
In the article by Labaree the three reasons that he lists for why schools should exist or be used consist of either democratic equality where he talks about this focusing on preparing citizens; social efficiency which focuses on training workers or social mobility, which, prepares individuals for social positions.
ReplyDeleteAs a class unit we agreed that school is in place to help us to get a career to make money, it is there for knowledge and empowerment and knowledge being a source of power by which we can get other things accomplished and we saw school as a means of creating citizens to live in the world and change it.
I think that looking at these two lists they are very similar in nature. We as a class agreed that in some shape, the democracy of the world, where we create citizens is important just as Labaree had thought. In conjunction with this, I think that as a unit this should be focused on. We should be prepping the next generation to be people. I don't think that Labaree left anything out because these three goals of schools that he had are such large umbrellas that other things could fit underneath it. Although we as a class came up with a group list, in individual group settings there were other things that were stated that might not be mentioned such as the opportunity for growth in addition to the opportunity to feel loved and have that need be fulfilled by teachers. I also think that these could go under one of the umbrella terms that Labaree suggests as being a goal for schools.
Other thoughts that I had were that the breakdown of each of the goals of school that Labaree had were broken down in a nice way. Also, I liked how they all fit into each other. There was a way that democratic equality went with social mobility or that social mobility intertwined with social efficiency. The goal and overall motive of school is inefficient without another part.
Zoe
There were plenty of points made in the article which we mentioned in our class discussion, and how they intersect with history. The purposes of education, as found in Labaree's article, discuss how it prepares students for work life/getting them ready for labor and taking direction, preparing members of a democratic system, and preparing them to compete in social situations (Work). In class, we did not really mention competition, and were focused more on self fulfillment, and how realization and independence can build confidence in our citizens, therefore having contributing members.
ReplyDeleteIn the three points that we came up with during class, we were able to recognize how the education system is failing in each purpose. Labaree calls this an adaption to inequality, which is true when we take our time contemplating issues and not taking action. The article also discusses the the conflict that occurs when trying to satisfy all these purposes, and how they can often contradict each other. This is something we talked about in class, especially when we mentioned the politics, under the new administration.
When comparing Labaree’s list for having public schools (democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility), it’s clear that it begins to mirror the list that we created in class. However, he goes on to discuss how this list is implemented depending on who is benefiting from education. In a perfect world, we would all benefit from education (and in some ways, we do), but I think it’s important to think about how this benefit is different dependent on the stakeholder. I enjoyed reading the different perspectives as I hadn’t thought about that when making our list in class. From a teacher’s perspective, I believe we often focus on his version of democratic equality. Despite a big push to “teach to the test”, we want our students to be quality members of society and to feel as if they have a voice.
ReplyDeleteI found it incredibly interesting that Labaree stressed how focusing on one goal can often be at the expense of another. On the surface, it seems as if all of these three goals mesh together. If we are teaching our students to be great citizens and instilling a hard work ethic in them, they should easily be able to get a job and move up the social ladder, right? Well, we all know that it doesn’t work that way. It’s not that simple and that only some people benefit from education in that manner. When you dig deeper into these goals, primarily by looking at the stakeholder or beneficiary of the goal, one can find conflict. And this conflict makes sense. It’s clear that some goals are the current primary focus of education and explains why there are such disparities in the quality of education a child can receive. Additionally, I believe this conflict may play a role into teacher turnover- teachers who are asked to implement all three goals, but are truly only evaluated on one. They may have successfully implemented all three goals, but when a district is only looking at one, that superb teacher then looks average. While this conflict is not the only accounting factor of both quality of education and teacher turnaround, it allows for an interesting perspective of education. Labaree challenges his readers to think about the purpose of education much like we did in class. It is easy to begin listing the purposes of education, but harder to start specifically listing these reasons and begin relating them to one another. As teachers, I think most of us wish for a just education system, but what does that include? Is it enough to have public education that benefits one party the most (and often isn’t necessarily the direct consumer of education-the student)? I think this is a hard question to answer. The solution to better education undoubtedly lies in all three goals, which is why it’s so hard to find an effective solution. With this being said, I agree with Labaree that society is pushing towards promoting mainly the social mobility goal. The only problem with this is that it’s not really promoting social mobility for all- just the ones who have access, as he mentions with the importance of reputation, grades, and social competition.
The only aspect of Labaree’s article that wasn’t portrayed in our list was the sense of empowerment. He discussed the idea of using knowledge as a means to make money, to have security, or to set oneself apart from the crowd, but not as a way to feel empowered, to feel inspired. Education shouldn’t be a one-trick show. It should be giving students the opportunity to better their lives, but also the sense that they are in control, not society. Right now, society, for many, is in control. I’m looking forward to learning more about the possible solutions to these issues and how we can effectively implement all three of these goals to ensure that every child is receiving a purposeful, empowering, and just education.
-Alexis Wilkes
Labaree's article aligns with three of the points from our list, but does not address empowerment through knowledge, as we discussed in class. The history of Labaree's three purposes for schools is beneficial and in a way crucial to understanding the three purposes themselves, and I found it interesting to read about historically why these purposes are so important. We didn't go much further after identifying the purposes of education we found important, and it would have taken much longer to go further beneath the surface, but Labaree does with subcategories for each purpose. For Democratic Equality, he goes further to into citizenship training, equal treatment, and equal access, which were all points that were brought up during our brainstorming before identifying the main purposes. When Labaree discusses social mobility, he highlights that students quickly replace the understanding that knowledge is important, with he understanding that its credentials (grades, etc.) that get them where they want to be. He explains that the value of knowledge is in turn the value of grades or credentials and eventually money. This understanding is what motivates students toward success. Our discussion in class did not seem to get to this point, but I feel Labaree touches on many topics below the surface of our discussion, that is based on the same purposes for education. As others have said, the purposes align to the purposes we listed in class, but Labaree goes a little deeper into each purpose, and does not discuss the sense of empowerment, but rather discusses the motivation for competition, money, and credentials to succeed in life.
ReplyDeleteKatie Fulton
I believe that the list has a lot of similarities and very few differences with Labaree's article. Labaree says that American education has three goals: democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility. These three goals directly relate to our list. We discussed how schools should focus on preparing citizens (democratic equality), focus on training workers (social efficiency), and preparing individuals to compete for social positions (social mobility).
ReplyDeleteIn addition, Labaree talks a lot about how politics and political views have a strong effect on how we perceive schools and how schools and school issues should be handled. This idea and thought was something that we listed in class as well. Personally, I believe it goes deeper, "What are your morals? How do you decipher what is right or wrong? What influences your beliefs about education?" I believe that politics may play a huge role but beliefs play a more significant role because beliefs shape your political ideology. Labaree touched on this topic, starting on page 71, when he started to discuss credentialism. The theme of humility and pride both resonated with me when I read this. On one hand, you are humble about your credentials so you very rarely discuss them. Then on the other hand you worked hard for your credentials so you should be proud and not devalued. This is directly related to morality and values because humility and pride ultimately stems from what you believe in.
As I said previously, Labaree took a more political approach to this topic. I believe that this was a great approach because it showed how politics are heavily involved in the education world. In contrast, I believe that he did leave out the more "ethical" side of this subject. As we discussed in the class, power equals money when it comes to society's outlook of power and influence. This subject lead us in the discussion of how teachers have to teach for career building in order for students to build that money, and to teach for students to be culturally knowledgeable and want change. We said that we need to teach the students that the more money you have, the more lives you can impact, especially/specifically those who are in the same situation that you once were in. Also, we need to teach these two subjects together because a strong career with financial stability is pointless without helping others (which goes back morality and values).
SABRINA EVANS.
DeleteLabaree identified three reasons to why public schools exist, which were similar to the ones we, as a class, identified on Tuesday. He stated the three principal reasons were social mobility, social efficiency, and democratic equality. However, Labaree left out the idea of public schools as a source for empowerment. Although social mobility or democratic equality is somewhat similar to empowerment, Labaree stressed social mobility as a “private good.” Opposed to empowerment, social mobility allows individuals to build credentials through public schooling, resulting in an ability to move up or stay in the current socio-economic status.
ReplyDeleteLabaree, additionally, highlighted how each of these three principals often clashes with each other. I found his portrayal of these principals as often being in conflict extremely interesting. Although, Labaree points out social mobility can bring about democratic equality or vice versa, his argument stressed the differences between each principal. In contrast, I think social mobility, democratic equality, and social efficiency can be achieved cooperatively. For example, I think RTR is an example of both a social mobility and efficiency-based program. We, as RTR students, achieve a vocational training as teachers in graduate school (efficiency-based), while also gaining more educational credentials, through a master’s degree (mobility-based). In addition, the program focuses on training teachers, who “check their privilege at the door” to provide equal treatment of future students. After all, this is a class that familiarizes us with the ethics of teaching. Although, Labaree stated schools should and can balance these three principals but the tasks remains hard in practice, when so many interests pull education from one principal to another.
I disagreed with his notion that social mobility cannot achieve community uplift. As mentioned above, Labaree characterized social mobility as a “private good” versus a “public good”, like democratic equality or social efficiency-based education. I think community uplift can be achieved through the individual opposed to strictly being based on community engagement.
However, Labaree made an excellent point in emphasizing how social mobility essentially curtails education to a pyramid hierarchical structure, with a top-down order. Labaree excellently displayed how performance-based curriculum standards have pushed education towards social mobility, where the primary concern is passing tests to achieve grades and credentials. Furthermore, I agree with Labaree that education has become very “meritocratic,” just like the corporate world, where learning and becoming engaged in the material is becoming less important.
-Tyler Arnold
Labaree’s three categories are democratic equality, social efficiency, or social mobility. The list in class that we created included: equal opportunity, access to careers, knowledge empowerment, chance to choose, and democratic citizenship. I don’t think any of the three categories really touch on knowledge for empowerment, however I don’t think knowledge for empowerment has to be an exclusive reasons for public education. I believe that all three categories hit on equal opportunity in theory but Labaree does a good job at explaining that the hopes for public education are different than the reality. Democratic citizenship matches with democratic equality however Labaree highlights the idea of shaping political leaders than total citizenship which I think includes voting, understanding democracy, and being involved in more ways that just running for office (such as being an informed citizen about what is happening in your community). Access to careers matches with social efficiency however in the article it focuses on the idea that taxpayers/ business owners want public education for trained individuals to work for them. Chance to choose and social mobility loosely tie into each other, for Labaree social mobility is part of private free markets that are trying to create competition in market roles. I don’t think in class we really talked about the privation of education since we focused on what public education should do. Labree argues the biggest threat to public education in having social mobility be the guiding goal of education which further moves education into a private good. One of the political problems in education in balancing “freedom” and “inequalities. Labree uses an example of Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamlinton’s competing economic views. Hamilton believes that total capitalism and economic freedom leads to a highly unequal distribution of wealth and power however Jefferson argues restricting economic freedom to address inequality infringes on individual liberty which is dangerous to sustaining a democracy. In Labree article it seems like democratic equality would be the model that would want public education to emphasis knowledge for empowerment and but would not address inequalities and inequities.
ReplyDelete- Jessica Diaz
In class I remember there being a focus on the advancement of society and the creation of opportunity as some of the main purposes of public education. Labaree touches on those points more deeply with his three reasons for public education, democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility. Like in our class the purpose of the advancement of society fell into the democratic equality category and the choice of opportunity fell into the social mobility argument. However, I would argue that while social mobility may provide choices and opportunities for some, those choices are restricted by class, gender and race as opposed to "individual achievement," as argued by Labaree. (60) I do agree that social mobility is a result of a culture of individualism that is perpetuated through the commodification of education.
ReplyDeleteI think that the consumerism and individualism of American culture continues to place more value on the worth of education in terms of wealth and social mobility.These value systems are perpetuated by politicians who are elected and create policies that perpetuate consumerism, simply because it directly benefits them, but also they keep getting elected. Labaree argued, politics is the problem with our education system. (40) The constant political fighting over the purpose of education by progressives and conservatives has led to a stagnation in vision and has let the the contradictions and cross purposes muddle the goals of education.( 71) With our current political climate, it has become more important to attempt to influence education locally since the federal level of policy making has become so divisive.
If our values as a society remain focused on individualism, consumerism, and divisiveness, then our schools will continue to be spaces focused on meritocracy that perpetuate the advancement of those who have access to resources and skills that determine who is socially mobile via education. Our values in our society are reflected in our politicians who are elected then perpetuate policies that promote a more limited sense of social mobility as a purpose for education. Labaree showed that the purpose of education had been swayed more heavily by his three purposes at different times historically depending on the national political consciousness. I agree, that in order for education to have a clear vision that promotes social advancement in terms of creating good citizens and providing choices, American cultural values need to drive the national political discourse to create policies that will drive those purposes. In my opinion, education is a symptom of a larger systemic cultural and political problem which values the worth of wealth more than civic democratic society. That is why as teachers we need to promote the cultural change from within our classrooms that will one day lead to political change. Labaree was very poignant to quote Horace Mann, "...private fortunes are among the greatest dangers to which the happiness of the people of the republic can be subjected."(45)
-Nick Bergheimer
We stated that public education should create equal opportunity, career advancement, the chance to choose, empowerment through knowledge, and strengthened democratic citizenship. David Labaree focuses on democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility as the three often conflicting goals of education. Many connections between lists were present, while a noticeable difference in who these goals are working to benefit was presented by Labaree.
ReplyDeleteDemocratic equality as described by Labaree (1997) is fairly similar to our comments on the topic of democratic citizenship; in the view of all students as citizens, there is equality and school is a way to strengthen this equal political competence (p. 42). Our comments in class focused on the need (and current lack) for students to leave school with an informed place in democracy; both our class and Labaree agree that this informed democracy can be attained through the creation of a similar knowledge base (starting with similar classes in schools). Our thoughts on democratic equality as a class aligned with Labaree mostly because we acknowledged that every student has access to this. Social efficiency is closely related to our class topic of career advancement, although as a class we didn’t discuss the logistics of this idea. Labaree discusses that social efficiency relies on the idea that productivity within the occupational marketplace is for everyone, and that school should be focusing on jobs instead of any similar base knowledge for students. While this idea of everyone going to school for a place in the occupational market seems as if it would create equality, Labaree also states that diplomas from different high schools and colleges do not allow for these students to receive the same occupations. As a class, we discussed careers and the chance to choose as being available to everyone who receives an education (ideally), and Labaree approaches this idea of efficiency with the same hesitance. Lastly, social mobility relates to our class idea of having the choice to choose, although this goal views school as a private good in Labaree’s article. In social mobility, education is seen as a commodity that puts certain consumers at an advantage in social situations. Education is no longer collective under the lens of social mobility; this goal of education focuses on the individual and what opportunities they alone can receive from schools. Labaree explains this goal by discussing that the elite are able to best receive social mobility by purchasing the goods needed (a house in the right district, a degree from an Ivy League institution, etc.). Inequality has a large place in social mobility; inequality was something that we discussed directly in the topic of a chance to choose, but one that I believe was silently agreed upon.
Our class list coincides with Labaree’s to an extent, but there are differences in their viewpoints and those who benefit. We discussed our list in the context of everyone who receives public education; every student should receive equal opportunity, career advancement, the viewpoint of knowledge as power, the chance to choose, and democratic citizenship. As many previous classmates have commented, Labaree argues that many of the categories he presented (democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility) often work against each other; while democratic equality and social efficiency can work to benefit everyone, social mobility only works for a select few. Had we spent time talking about the realistic expectations versus reality of these goals of education, I believe that we would have come to many of the same conclusions about inequality and personal gain as Labaree. A difference between lists was the idea that knowledge as power doesn’t fit into one of the three categories presented by Labaree; this could be its own goal for public education with its benefits and implications. Overall, I feel as if there were many connections between our goals and those of Labaree.
-Brooke Lock
In class, we discussed many of the ideas that Labaree addresses such as the goal of education to develop democratic citizens, breed contributing members to the workforce, and provide equal opportunities. However, we didn’t talk about how some of these can come into conflict with one another. Labaree discusses the difficulty in finding a balance among the goals for education and who benefits from them.
ReplyDeleteWe collectively prioritized equal access to opportunities and addressed the merits of producing contributing working members of society without diving into possible contradictions these might pose. Social efficiency “promotes the sorting of students” which “leads to the limitation of opportunities for these students” going against one of the goals on our class list (Labaree, 1997, pg 50). Labaree pointed out preparing people for the workforce or to be contributing members of society can contradict the goal of providing equal opportunities. While democratic equality and social efficiency feed back and support the society, social mobility looks at education as a more private or personal acquisition.
I thought it was interesting that Labaree referred to democratic equality and social efficiency as a public good and social mobility as a private good. I haven’t thought about the goals of education in these terms, but that is very much what drives society views and support or lack of support of schools and education. As Labaree states, society lacks “public love” without payment when looking at education (pg 62). There isn’t support for providing and nurturing each child as an individual but rather there is a focus on producing members that help support and benefit the society. While I (along with the class as shown in our collective list) think all of these goals are important in education, I relate to this last goal the most as a driving force in my own aspiration to teach these children.
I think Labaree explained the possible benefits and negatives to each of the goals for education and where they each might cause dissonance for one another. It would have been beneficial to have examples of possible propositions for how to meld these goals which seemed to be lacking.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI believe that while the language used was slightly different, the ideals for public education that we came up with in class were the same that were found in the Labaree article. He articulates democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility as the primary reasons for education, while we said democratic citizenship, having a career and making money, and empowerment were the primary reasons. Stripping these terms down from particular nuances the meaning is the same across the three broad categories.
ReplyDeleteThe democratic piece is essential because of the political system that our students live in, and in which they will (hopefully) participate as adults. So, schools should teach children in a way to make them informed citizens that will be able to analyze issues and be politically active, as well as instill morals and insights into what is right so that they will make good choices. I find this goal slightly ironic, considering that the only time we teach civics, politics, or government to student is briefly in elementary school, in 8th grade, and in the 12th grade. Just speaking from personal experience, most people know very little about their government and the way it functions. Social efficiency is basically the socialization of children to be productive members of society, and the way that that is usually described is by getting a job so you can be useful and engage with society and help it run smoothly, rather than being unemployed or homeless (which are seen from a societal view as negative). I say that social mobility and empowerment are extremely similar because they have similar goals. Those who generally strive for greater mobility are those who live at the bottom of the social hierarchy, and the best way to achieve this mobility is through empowerment (and reparations, although that’s another story).
Just as a side note, I found it surprising that in none of Labaree’s categories or in our discussion did the reason of self-fulfillment or a sort of “species being” (from Karl Marx) come up. This refers to reaching a person’s own utmost potential and creating an environment in which they can be the best they can be at whatever they choose to be. This is always what I’d sort of believed education should be, and I think that the other categories we developed could even fit inside of it. To build people up to reach their full potential they will become better democratic citizens, they will have a meaningful career, they would be empowered, as well as reaching a certain level of personal happiness, which I like to think is also a goal we should have for our children.
Abbey Brown
I agree with you about self-fulfillment, as I think most of our class mates would, but I think the hard part is how to actually implement this. I think Montessori schools, with their emphasis on children following their own interests, might be a model for public schools to emulate.
DeleteLabaree discusses the three “alternative goals” of education as democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility. He goes even further to label each as either a public or private good and explains that each goal comes from a specific perspective, that of a citizen, a taxpayer, or a consumer. His goals closely resemble the list we generated as a class, despite a difference in language.
ReplyDeleteWhile Labaree discusses social efficiency, we termed it “career”, referring to career identification, development, and training. I agree with Labaree that this particular goal comes from the employer, and taxpayers, who demand prepared and trained workers to fill prescribed roles. This is perhaps the most obvious goal of public education, made evident by the educational requirements listed at every job posting. While some roles may require a specific degree or training, others specify a GED or high school diploma, and nearly all mandate that the worker be able to read and write.
Labaree also describes social mobility as a goal, which he views as a competition between students for “desirable social positions”. This definition loosely translates to our discussion of the “chance to choose” in life and has the same underlying reasoning, albeit different ultimate purposes. Labaree describes social mobility from the perspective of the consumer, labeling it a private good used to obtain a competitive edge over other consumers. Our own discussion was far more altruistic. We focused on the idea of opportunity to choose as a deeply personal goal without a purpose in a competitive job market. The idea of choice is more akin to freedom than to a social competition.
On the third goal of education, democratic equality, our class was in complete agreement with Labaree. From the perspective of a citizen, education’s purpose is to create responsible and competent citizens who are capable of participating in our society. This is certainly a public good as it specifically serves society as a whole.
As a future educator, the most important goal I have for public education is to build knowledge and empower students. Labaree fails to mention the idea of building knowledge as a specific goal of education, possibly because it loosely falls into the idea of social efficiency in the form of preparation and training. I would argue that building knowledge is its own separate goal and requires particular attention and effort. An interest in knowledge and a feeling of empowerment is the foundation on which the other three goals stand, for without them a student will have no interest in career, competing, or the society around them.
Maranda Miller
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWe discussed in class that public education should provide: equal opportunity, career preparation, individual empowerment, choice, and promote democratic citizenship. Labaree describes his three goals of education: preparing democratic citizens, promoting social efficiency, and promoting social mobility. He correlates each to a citizen's goal, a taxpayer's goal, and a consumer's goal, respectively. In all, I think that we as a class touched on most of the ideas Labaree presented in a more broad way. Some of our class points overlap with Labaree's goals. For instance, choice and individual empowerment can be lumped into Labaree's social mobility goal. In this goal, the consumer seeks the best education for personal benefit regardless of the need of the community, economy, or political environment. Labaree's social efficiency goal matches with our class goal of career preparation. In this case, the taxpayer dictates what the economy needs and therefore what the education system should promote and encourage. Finally, both our class and Labaree agree that a goal of education systems should be to prepare democratic citizens. While Labaree states throughout that our society has shied away from emphasizing this goal as our country has grown, I still think this goal should be an important cornerstone in education. It seemed that both mobility and efficiency could include promoting and creating good, well educated "republicans." The challenges Labaree discusses towards the end of his essay outline what I hope to gain through thoughtful discussion today with the class. I found myself going back and forth as to which goal I supported. It is a tough problem to solve, yet the fundamental foundation of democracy is compromise and that our society's ebb and flow should allow for success at all levels of education.
ReplyDelete-Brian Condit
Similar to Labree’s list we made a big point of focusing on our public schools use as a resource for educating and creating citizens prepared to live in a democracy is spot on with Labree’s first goal of public education. Our other two points where either symptoms or consequences of his other two goals of american education.
ReplyDeleteHe cites Gutmann and Hirsch’s statement that our public education should prepare citizens “to participate intelligently as adults in the political process that shapes their society.” This notion is the very essence of having an equal and just government, a government of the people, by the people, for the people. Now, is this always the case of public school systems? No. As he asserts in section on social mobility, their will always be disparities. As is the nature of a capitalist society, people are always seeking the best for themselves or their children, to gain that edge over someone else. The very notion that someone would want to move their child to a better school means somebody else would be left with the lesser option and impede on their social mobility. Our idea of schools as a tool for social efficiency, while thoughtful in theory, has also impeded students social mobility. The inherent differences in the education that comes along with sorting students into different levels of education is flawed. While they may be receiving an education that challenges them in the classroom it may not necessarily reflect on standardized scores in turn affecting their social mobility. Our social mobility and efficiency have a large impact on our security as person. They directly impact what opportunities we have access to and where we end up in our lives. If looked at as having three major functions, at our point in time now, society has chosen to focus on the social mobility branch more so than the other two. Currently placing more emphasis on prestige than an equitable and quality education.
-Adam Darby
How knew, the list from Labaree and the list we listed in class are very similar. Our list was more about equity and equal opportunities, empowerment, democratic citizenship, and chose to chose. Similarly, Labaree stated that democratic equality; schools shuld focus on preparing citizens, social mobility; school should prepare individuals to compete for social positions, and social efficiency; school should focus on training workers.
ReplyDeleteLabaree goes on and talks about each of the educational goal. What I walk away from this article is there are just so much people want public school ( teachers, us), to do and there is a very little supports we got. In addition, each goal is opposite to one another, public good and private good.
It is sad that we are one nation, under God, but we have opposite view. While taxpayer and citizen want to educate an over all people equally and fair, the consumer said that we should not do that because people who work hard for it deserve better. In away, education system or level attainment place people in different class. It become a part of the game where people who are ahead gets all and make sure people behind will not catch up them easily.
One thing I notice missing from this article was morality. This might sound like religious thing but it is not. It common sense and it vital in our society. While we are so busy teaching our children about everything, SOL, or pursuing educational goal, we forgot to teach our next generation of our children to be good people. People with common sense, nice, understanding. I believe if we the people, from the most powerful citizen in our capital to the homeless citizen on street, have good in ourselves, we will be in a much better place.
I completely agree with you Asein! The author list one view and fails to look at it from any other; which is what others do as well. He focused on his thoughts and what schools should focus and not on what they’re doing in comparison. As discussed in class, we described public education as valuable and something that all people should have the access to with the proper resources.
DeleteI did notice that time and time again education is looked at from a capitalist view point. I believe this hinders the school system resulting negatively for the students. Students start to learn just to earn any job, or for the credentials and not for the excitement of the knowledge. Many teachers struggle to motivate their students and often feel it is not their duty, but in order to help these students grow we need to. I’ve heard one of the most intelligent students say they’ll be a mechanic just because their father is. To me, that sounds like no one motivated them to be the best they could be. If it is not being done at home, then school has to be that place where they can be encouraged to be all that they can. Teaching is more than academics and that’s what politics fail to realize.
Brandi Veasey
Isn't motivation to be the best you can be part of the Social Mobility goal? That is, isn't it in the consumer's or individual's interest to be the best they can be? Maybe in the social mobility arena, the individual must be self-motivated. That may be the fundamental idea of this goal. It's not in the best interest of the employer for the individual to be the best person, just the best employee. Likewise, a citizen is more concerned at the student becoming a good citizen.
DeleteKatie S.
ReplyDeleteLabaree breaks down the overall goals and views of education into three categories, all of which we touched on one way or another in class. In our class list, we included education as a means for empowering citizens to become involved in democracy, as a way to equip people with practical skills that can make them valuable members of the work force, which in turn can help give people more social and economic mobility. We included a few more goals of public education, but overall, our list relates to Larabee's.
Larabee goes further in breaking these goals down into two categories: public good and private good. He sees democratic equality and social efficiency (training workers) as public goods, and social mobility as a private good. I agree with his assessment that our educational system has suffered due to conflict between these conflicting categories. However, I'm not certain I entirely agree with his claim that the focus of our educational system has shifted towards a consumer perspective. He says that now, the focus is on the pursuit of credentials rather than knowledge. As far as our culture's approach to higher education, I agree with his sentiment. But when it comes to grade school, especially in the earlier years, I don't know that the focus has skewed quite as much.
Although our class list compares pretty well to Labaree's list, it seemed that ours focused pretty heavily on democratic equality. We felt that ideally, education should empower people, especially by giving people equal treatment and equal access to quality education at any level.
Labaree gave perspective to the issue of school reform that I had not ever considered. His three reasons for schools; democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility, were all represented in our lists. I knew schools were often plagued by politics, Labaree's breakdown of the competing interests gave me a greater understanding of the issues we see in school reform. While there is overlap, these interests do contradict one another. Americans seem remiss to admit its true reasons for public education, but maybe we just don't know. As Labaree stated "As a resultof being forcedto muddleits goals and continually work at cross-purposes, education inevitably turns out to be deficient in carrying out any of these goals very effectively."
ReplyDeleteI agree with Labaree that America should narrow its goals.We should continue to fight the structures that minoritize groups, so that social mobility is possible for those who seek it regardless of race, gender, religion and other factors. Yet, a focus on assuming rights and responsibilities as a citizen and intrinsic achievements rather than status might lead to a better functioning society and take the politics out of our schools. In our uncertain times, there is the possibility for change. We can redefine success in America, starting with our schools.
Laubree has three categories that he discusses: democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility. Democratic equality is teaching the youth to be productive citizens so that we may trust in their future decisions to lead us. Social efficiency says that how well we are doing economically directly effects our ability to prepare the youth. Social mobility is the theory that school is designed to create an advantage for our students in the competition for good market roles.
ReplyDeleteDuring our last class, we discussed a variety of reasons for public school. One that was common among us and stuck out was equality. Laubree suggests that to achieve equality, schools must focus on building citizenship and relative equality. The list we designed in class does closely align with his three categories, but there are some things left out.
Like Katie said, there was nothing discussed about empowerment through knowledge. We had a long discussion about this in class and I feel that it is one of the most important aspects of education. While this article focuses on more of the political side of education, I firmly believe that the ethical side is just as important. Empowerment through knowledge will allow our students to go far in life in whatever they choose to do. In class, we talked about how knowledge can allow our students to not be take advantage of. The more knowledge they have, the better their understanding, and the further they can go. We also discussed that through this, the students have a better understanding of themselves and are less likely to be molded into what society says they are.
Another thought I had while reading this article is that on page 40, he discusses the changes that could be made within schools. He mentions Black academies as one. In TEDU 626 we recently discussed race in schools. It is inevitable that by being in this program, all of us will be teaching at predominantly black schools. Keeping in mind that to some of us, this culture is different. I think it speaks volumes that some people believe creating all black academies could benefit education. A lot of times, young teachers go into the schools wanting to change these children. Having a point of reference to understand this culture, instead of wanting to “fix” it can make all the difference.
-Morgan Mathews