Tues. May 30


Tues. May 30 - Are Payne’s critics being fair?  What did you find that was useful or illuminating in Payne’s text? Comment on whether/how deficit thinking has been present in your own thinking. 

Comments

  1. I think this article brings up points that contradict Payne's arguments and rightly points them out to be assumed stereotypes for the most part. I thought it was particularly dangerous to teach other teachers that poverty is a behavior that can be described through stereotypes such as laziness, violence, chronically unemployed, etc.. I think this is dangerous because if poverty is a behavior that is passed down generationally, then what motivation does that give the teacher in trying to empower a student from a low SES background? Payne is essentially saying that the poor can be identified through certain characteristic and behavior traits and that teachers should take note and not expect the same as they would from a middle class student. It makes being in poverty the "other" to the middle class and promotes a norm that she believes through her own assumptions rather than research.

    I was surprised that Payne's book sold over a million copies by now, so I looked on amazon to read the comments. Most of the educators that commented were very happy with the book and made the comment that it opened their eyes to poverty and that they could now better teach students from low SES backgrounds. On the one hand the intent is good, but the implications of teaching while reinforcing these stereotypes upon students and why they may behave a certain way because they are poor, puts the onus on the student, as the article suggested. I agree with the conclusion of the article that deficit thinking does not look at the political and institutional problems of society, like the lack of equal access to heath care or the stress financial uncertainty may have on a family and a student daily. It would be interesting to know how this book has actually impacted an educator and their approach to teaching.

    While I was reading this article I had the thought that I have held some of these assumptions before and I had to ask myself, where do they come from? I think a lot of them were upheld through daily media coverage from when I was a kid and probably somewhat today. I remember when the media covered the perceived problem of gangster rap entering into the mainstream culture and there was a political backlash that outlined some of these same stereotypes. The nightly news reported stories of violent crime, the war on drugs, and welfare queens usually through similar stereotypes depicted in Payne's book. I think there was a social conditioning that occurred through the media that I had to unlearn and and begin asking myself why I may have believed a certain idea, whether it was about politics, race, class, gender, etc. I still find myself trying to be aware as possible and I hope to avoid deficit thinking and address each student as their own individual with there own story.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. Nick, I completely agree with your ideas about Payne's argument being dangerous for teachers. The mindset that Payne presents breeds an absolution from responsibility for anyone wealthy or in the middle class. By assuming that poverty is actually behavioral, not economical, Payne ignores a student's needs and instead places an additional (and unnecessary) burden on them.

      Delete
    3. Nick, I am with you on the idea that a lot of Payne's claims might come from daily media coverage. It was so clear that stereotyping in this article.

      Delete
  2. This article brings up many points that go against Payne’s beliefs toward poverty. These critics mention countless times that her writing hardly ever comes from research. They disproved her several times in this article through researching her claims and finding valid resources that contradict her writing. An example of that is when Payne mentions that there are only three classes of people in the United States. This article states that Payne sees the world as having poor, wealthy, and middle class. They go on to say that the world isn’t so neatly divided into these three groups but instead there are 6. One point that I found particularly interesting was the fact that Payne doesn’t ever mention race and ethnicity in her findings but 6 out of 9 of her fictional case studies deal with people of color. This creates a stereotype that people of color make up most of the poverty population when in fact, it is white people.

    As a future teacher, it was hard to read some of the claims she made. One that really made me cringe was the fact that she sees poverty as behavioral. She mentions that someone’s financial situation can have nothing to do with whether they are considered living in poverty, but the way they behave CAN put them in that category. It’s disheartening to think that teachers are using this as a foundation of building relationships with children. I agree with Nick when he says: “On the one hand the intent is good, but the implications of teaching while reinforcing these stereotypes upon students and why they may behave a certain way because they are poor, puts the onus on the student, as the article suggested.” Maybe her intent was good, but when it’s put against valid research it’s hard to feel like it wasn’t written solely based on opinion.

    When I reflect on my own self, I must be honest in saying that deficit thinking has been present in my mind before. Mostly because of a lack of knowledge in that department. I was never exposed to a diverse group of people going through school. I come from a small town where we all grew up mostly the same. Poverty wasn’t an issue in my town and therefore never a topic of conversation. I love learning these new things and seeing stereotypes and long misinformed judgements being broken. It’s particularly important for us because we will be teaching in areas with children from poverty. I hope to take away as much as I can from this and stay conscious of the fact that deficit thinking is often hurtful to the students and myself as an educator.

    - Morgan Mathews

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Morgan I definitely agree with you statement with how Payne’s view undermines moral values and fails to see where her privilege is present. Payne goes on to mention how she reinforced her study, through living near an impoverish area. Living near an impoverish area has little to none effect on the community. We can see that here is Richmond, where across the highway there are neighborhoods that are in poverty, and the other side looks newly built. Many people make their own assumptions of why and can observe the community, but will not truly understand the difficulties and arduous trials these go through without listening and being a part of that lifestyle.

      It’s not that I have not been aware of how people can be oblivious to how the system works for people who are in poverty or oppressed, but through Payne’s article it is very apparent that our country in in dire need of a change. It amazes me that people can have great credentials, but still they lack knowledge of the society they live in now. It’s almost as if we’re able to become educated, not even become experts, on poverty why haven’t these people with these credentials seem adherent to these issues. This shows where our country is at this day and age, and what issues need to be taken care of.

      As a student who was raised in poverty, but never knew it, deficit was not really on my mind. I always knew my mother worked really hard for everything my siblings and I had. Everything we needed, we had and that was enough. When my mother was a child she lived in various countries and had friends of various backgrounds, which allowed my family and I to never think twice about others and what they have. Even when I would see people who were homeless I would not think negatively about them, but would rather think of how this happened or where they sleep at night.

      Delete
  3. The analysis of Bomer, et al, on Payne’s views on class structure, educational goals, and techniques for teachers were pointed and well supported by legitimate research. As a scientist, I found the research based approach very effective in communicating the main question: were Payne’s techniques advantageous for students of low economic status. It seems that Payne oversimplified the problem we have educators and utilized the natural need for order rather than trying to tackle the large, societal issues that our class society has created. Firstly, by simplifying the class structure into three classes (poverty, middle class, and wealth), Payne empowered the educator to establish the idea that the knowledge a student from poverty is somehow inferior. This allows the teacher to focus on the knowledge the poor student is lacking rather than the experiences and qualities the student possess; reinforcing the current social structure – keep the poor, poor. Bomer goes on to rebuke this idea giving evidence to the multiple social classes, the evidence of language of the poor, and family value analysis.

    I did not find much of Payne’s argument particularly useful, but I often sided with Bomer’s rebuttals that resembled mostly the antithesis of Payne’s main points. It strikes me as sad that an educator, Payne, I’m guessing, is motivated by easily grasped, convenient ideas for the sake of selling books. I’m sure she had good intentions, but the analysis by Bomer nearly nullifies Payne’s goals completely. As I previously stated, as a scientist, the research supported approach of Bomer may have promoted a bias for me. By oversimplifying the problem of poor students needs and blaming the individual students for the problems of education goals seems very irresponsible. I am even more disappointed by the conclusions made by Payne because they went hand in hand with a broken political goal (NCLB). The conservative approach to education is yet again being brought to the forefront of our society in DeVos’ school choice referendum. it scares me to think that there will be another educator/entrepreneur that will pounce on the opportunity to write an essay or book poorly supported by research to back that referendum in hopes to make a few bucks.

    As far as my own deficit thinking, I have definitely gained some of the same deficits Payne depicts. I think growing up in a “nice” neighborhood, going to “nice” schools, and playing organized sports allowed me to establish an attitude of how the world was and how “we” (my white, middle class family) acted in the world. I have recently tried to rationalize the “being poor is a state of mind,” comment that HUD Secretary Carson was recorded saying, and currently, I cannot. But, I think there was a time where I would believe that what I had, just was. I think to a certain extent, that naivety and innocence is present in all of us. But, as I’ve gained experiences, shared stories with others, educated myself, I’ve become more self-aware of the lifestyle I have had and how there are others that are no better than me that have large obstacles to overcome. And given the choice, I’m sure they would take them.

    -Brian Condit

    ReplyDelete
  4. Bomer’s analysis of Payne’s work suggests that Payne draws on several stereotypes to make inferences about American poverty and the role of the educator is overcoming such a state. As discussed in class last week, it is in our human nature to try to categorize things so we may better understand them. However, Bomer points out time and time again that Payne’s classifications are unsupported by research. Payne argues her work is a “cognitive approach…based upon a 32‐year longitudinal study of living next to and in a poverty neighborhood of mostly whites” (Payne, 2009). Apart from perpetuating stereotypes, I find it problematic that Payne assumes the goal of education is economic advancement. For one, Payne disregards the isms which oppress certain groups. For example, as Bomer points out, there are just as many white people living in poverty, so while Payne’s claim that a large percentage of people living born at the bottom see improvement in their lifetime might be true, it does not address the racial and gender distribution of this statistic.

    The success of Payne’s aha! Process is an important reminder for us to be critical consumers of research. Both Bomer and Payne hold PhDs from respected universities and are well-versed in the issues of urban education. Yet Payne’s publications make some disagreeable, maybe even foolish, assumptions about socioeconomics and education. Payne’s perceived credibility is itself an example of dangerous stereotype. Many take her research at face value because of her initials. Many of Payne’s claims are supported by research. The problem is her training skews research to perpetuate stereotypes held by teachers. Bomer doesn’t make many claims about the nature of poverty in this article, but he does cite research which claims that most poor, urban families share “a belief in their own abilities; the determination to raise healthy children; the provision of loving environments; caring for children with tenderness and affection; structured home environments; a concern for children’s safety and well-being; and a valuing of children’s independence and competence (page 2512).” This is polarizing and again generalizes. I agree with Bomer on the pitfalls of Payne’s research, and it is an important reminder to be wary of any attempts to narrowly define such a broad topic as poverty.

    When I make first impressions, I often employ deficit thinking to size up an individual. These assumptions are a defensive tactic in new situations. It is uncomfortable to be conscious of my deficit thinking because it makes me feel at fault but it is a first step in breaking my patterns of thought and building real relationships, especially when I step in front of a classroom.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nicole, I think it's important how you drew from our "purposes of education" discussion last week and related Payne's ideas about economic advancement into your post. I also found it troubling that Payne suggested that teachers can help students from poverty become more likely the middle-class by teaching them certain skills in school. You bring up an important flip-side to the stereotypes mentioned in "A Framework for Understanding Poverty" - the idea that many believe Payne's research because of her perceived credibility. You bring up a lot of important points from Bomer's article.

      Delete

  5. I can begin by saying that, at the most general level, I agree with Payne’s basic premise that the conditions of poverty should be acknowledged and to some degree defined, and that teachers should maintain awareness of these conditions. And yes, in some situations, teachers should adjust their teaching strategies accordingly when working with students living in poverty.

    However, other than this basic concession, I agree with Payne’s critics in characterizing the content of her text as baseless to the point of classism and racism. I found myself frequently shocked at some of Payne’s claims, these ranging from “poor people like being in jail” to “poor mothers have multiple sexual partners”. Her fundamental idea that poverty is a “mindset” or a “culture” borders on cruelty, not subtly suggesting that poverty should be as easy to escape as it is to change your mind about something. This is a morally bankrupt way to appeal to an audience’s belief in the American Dream in order to justify and trivialize poverty.

    I think it is crucial to remember that Payne’s philosophies were at the height of popularity during the No Child Left Behind era, a product of the Bush administration. Keeping this right-wing political association in mind, it makes sense that Payne would choose to essentially blame those living in poverty for their own circumstances as opposed to identifying the structural injustices that contribute to poverty. When Payne characterizes the lower class as incompetent, prone to crime, and lazy, she is furthering the conservative narrative that the poor are undeserving of social welfare services.

    It is especially distressing that Payne’s philosophies are mainly directed to teachers. One can assume that most teachers are members of the middle class. By defining and contrasting the lower and middle class in the way that she does, Payne is telling teachers that they are better than their poor students, and that these students represent some sort of “other”. I can’t think of a worse way to prepare to teachers to be able to connect with and educate their students in a healthy or effective way.

    Reflecting on my own deficit thinking, it would be impossible to argue that I’ve never made assumptions about the lives of students in urban areas. Just the idea of an “urban student” can, in some ways, conjure an image that is limited in that it doesn’t account for the endless differences and unique traits that are found among a student body. The Bomer article mentioned that, after studying the homelife and structures of lower class families, more differences than similarities were found, which I think will be an important fact to remember as we move forward as teachers.

    Landon

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hadn't really thought about it, but placing this in the context of the neoliberalism of the Bush era makes a lot of sense. The total unwillingness to see any structural or historical causes of poverty, but rather to blame it on a lack of initiative, absolves the middle and upper classes of having any responsibility for their impoverished fellow countrymen. This in turn allows them to justify tightening up social spending while at the same time giving themselves massive tax cuts. It also allows for the sinister and perverse argument that welfare programs CAUSE poverty, by taking away incentives to work harder.

      Unfortunately, I think we're in for a lot more of this over the next few years.

      Delete
  6. The road to hell is paved with good intentions, as the cliche goes. This article shows how a seemingly positive decision by congress to improve the lot of an historically overlooked group has led to reinforcement of the very tropes and stereotypes that have long been a part of middle class America's idea of people in poverty. Ruby K. Payne, with her book "A Framework for Understanding Poverty," and her Aha Process, Inc., has made a fortune by perpetuating these ideas about people in poverty.

    Beneath the surface of this well written and meticulously argued piece is a seething anger at how Payne's ideas, ill-informed and baseless as they are, could have been adopted by schools in 38 states. By creating a category of student called "economically disadvantaged," congress inadvertently created a market for literature and training tools to help teachers--who are predominantly middle class, white and female--understand this new demographic. As the article puts it: "What at first seems like so many words has real effects on human beings."

    What's particularly pernicious about Payne's work is that she uses unsubstantiated truth claims about people living in poverty to reinforce a deficit perspective of poor people. The idea is that poor people (which in Payne's world view are a monolithic social group, cultural and linguistic differences being negligible) are poor because of an inherently inferior culture. The solution is to instill in them the values of the middle and upper classes. This view entirely overlooks the idea that poverty is structural, that minoritized groups have been systematically oppressed by the dominant classes. As the article says: "Those who may not fit neatly into the dominant groups' ways of being are defective, lacking in ability, and in need of being re-made so as to better resemble those from the dominant class."

    Reading this article made me think of our discussion about transformative knowledge that we had the other day. It's easy to see how one might buy into Payne's ideas about the inherent cultural failings of the poor, especially if that person is white and middle class themselves. Her description of the lives of people living in poverty fit neatly into the prejudices that those of use who grew up in the dominate culture have without necessarily being aware of. It's important that we, as future educators, bring a critical eye to everything we read, and not be too quick to buy into idea's like Payne's without first questioning them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Andrew, I like how you highlight the way our country has created the opportunity for someone like Ruby Payne to be so successful perpetuating her unsubstantiated truth claims, which are anything but the truth. It hadn't really occurred to me that the act of grouping students together under a label like "economically disadvantaged" created a void for Ruby Payne to fill. The idea of a market that capitalizes on informing teachers about their struggling students is both appalling and all too real.

      Delete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think that Payne's book is much based on her personal biases, assumptions and stereotypes. I was awed to read quotes from Payne's book. A part that stood out the most to me was what the article categorized under "families." This category included some of Payne's quotes that absurdly stated single family homes to be automatically prone to poverty. It went as far as to suggest that mother-centered families are an indicative of poverty...how deploring and offensive is this statement?

    The article also went into serious determination to call out Payne on her sources. Based on the article, much of Payne's "data" has no base or back-up research to support it--it seemed to be only based on her personal beliefs. Which, as stated on the article, creates doubts and questions as to why professional entities around the United States and Canada would use her "findings" to train school representatives.

    I do want to mention that I think Payne deserves a little bit of doubt. I have not read this book. I only have the comment reviews from Amazon (I searched the book, wondering why teachers/people would still buy it, and also found many five stars reviews--though, I know those "five stars" can be bought...), and the opposite side from the article. Digging further, I simply googled the title of the book and found several blogs dedicated to "unmask" Payne's book. http://rubypayneiswrong.blogspot.com/p/scholarship-debunking-payne.html this blogpost has tons of articles and scholarly written pieces that analyse Payne's work--let's say the majority of what I found has a negative understanding of Payne's book. So, I still ask myself why this book is such a great seller.

    My personal assumptions were noted when I took Payne's quiz. Much--if not all--of what was listed on each social class, I considered to be stereotypes of society; items on each list were generalizations made by society. In honesty, I considered these assumptions to be general knowledge/beliefs. These assumptions are obviously not indicative of the truth yet they are part of mainstream media, therefore accepted by society.

    ReplyDelete
  9. After reading Bomer’s article, I believe he does make some very valuable points when looking from a very research/analytical standpoint. However, I do believe that Ruby Payne’s critics were at times harsh. For example, they discuss Payne’s claims on poverty and it’s culture. As for the culture of poverty, Payne suggests that a poor individual re-creates his or her social position as a member of a family so that future generations remain in poverty. Looking back at the critics’ responses to both of these theories of Payne, I believe they looked at these scenarios through data lenses. It seems that they should have also looked at it from a lens of someone who grew up in a poverty environment.

    Recently, prior to this past week, I may have been like the critics wanting more data based research. However, this past Friday I went on a bus trip to Gilpin and Mosby Court with fellow classmates, professors and our tour guide who grew up in housing. It was not until I had this experience and hearing his story that I started to really understand what these children and families go through on a day-to-day basis. I can understand where Payne is coming from when she says the above claims about poverty and the culture of poverty. These families that continue to stay in housing/poverty because that is all that they know; it’s what feels normal. Our tour guide explained to us that those who sit around the corner of the small corner stores, along with many others, stopped dreaming long ago. They stopped dreaming when they felt that their dreams were no longer achievable. That is why they stay.

    After this experience and reading this article, I realized that we should be able to have data to back up our findings to help improve a system. However, when we are taken out of our comfort zone, we can gain far more compassion for others in poverty and are able to solidify plans such as the Teacher Residency Program.

    -Sydney Lilly

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think that Bomer is fair in his criticisms of Ruby Payne's ideas about education and poverty. As Bomer points out, Payne makes assumptions that are based more on stereotypes than evidence. For example, one of Payne's claims is that men in poverty are expected to be "fighters and lovers". Bomer rightfully points out that Payne does not cite any evidence that can support her claim. Furthermore, Bomer adds that there is no evidence for Payne's claim in research literature. Payne makes an even more extreme claim about women in poverty saying, "Sex will bring in money and favors. Values are important, but they don't put food on the table...". Again, Bomer fairly criticizes Payne's complete lack of evidence in making such a claim. Even when Payne uses evidence as basis for her claims her conclusions are still flawed. Bomer references Payne's claim that circumlocution is a product of poverty rather than linguistic heritage. Bomer corrects Payne by pointing out how Smitherman's research actually suggests that circumlocution is a characteristic of African-American language rather than poverty. Essentially, Payne's claim equated a racial practice with a practice of poverty.

    What I found most illuminating about Payne's text is how I myself have fallen for some popular notions of deficit thinking. Payne's idea of generational poverty was one where I had held similar beliefs. I had assumed that children were more susceptible to behaviors that would keep them in poverty because children, naturally, adopt behavior that is modeled by their parents. To be fair, this assumption is not one that is specific towards low-income families. I also assumed wealthier families unintentionally passed on behaviors that would help their children economically. While I maintain that parents do have a significant influence on some of these behaviors, I do see Bomer's argument about how different children can be from their parents. I think many people make this assumption about deficit thinking before thinking about the many different factors that influence a child outside of the family.

    ReplyDelete
  11. So for starters, I have not read Ruby Payne's book. I don't know if it was an assigned reading but I have not read this particular literature. Whew! Now that that's out of the way, I can address the critics. I have heard of this work by Payne before but I didn't think that the dissections that I found from this critique would be as bad. One thing that stuck out to me by these critics were the fact that Payne called her claims data without having any real research. As a prospective teacher, we rely heavily on data and research to effectively help us to teach and to find better ways to perform and succeed as teachers and for our students to do the same. Another thing that stuck out to me was how social class and poverty were brought up. These are two social structures that have set definitions with infinite possibilities within them. The last thing that I found alarming was how Payne felt about poverty and the culture of poverty. It was said that poverty is applied to those that have the mindset of the culture of poverty. The patterns of thoughts and interactions remain even if they get more money. The culture of poverty is the ability to leave poverty being more dependent on other resources. I think being of African American descent and growing up around those that were in different socioeconomic statuses than I was and even commenting on poverty really made me open my eyes to some of these things.

    For example, this past week, I had the opportunity to see poverty firsthand in several of Richmond's housing districts; more specifically Gilpin Court. People that live there don't really know much else than what is presented to them. They have dreams of making it out but they can't sometimes continue to fight and press their way out. They are poor although they probably wouldn't like to be. It's considered normal to them. Poverty also isn't a lifestyle that is chosen. Sometimes people are just born this way.

    I think that as a whole, the critics were fair in their dealings with Payne. Data and research are important for us to have in order to be well informed, but on the other hand we need to not be ignorant yet educated on the matter to be able to efficiently help our students, each other and their families.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Many of Ruby Payne’s claims within “A Framework for Understanding Poverty” do not actually help educators understand poverty, as the text mostly focuses on generalizations about poor people. One Amazon reviewer noted that finding out about the home lives of impoverished students is extremely important; I whole-heartedly agree with this statement, but we have very different ideas about credible sources for this information. Based on the lack of research-based evidence, discussion of factors (other than a culture of poverty) influencing poverty, and suggestions for educators to advocate for low SES students in their classrooms, I believe that Payne’s critics are fair.

    Payne’s claims, as Randy Bomer describes, are rooted in a deficit perspective that explains poverty as being caused by a set of behaviors, attitudes, and beliefs. Payne does not view low SES families as having funds of knowledge that are different than those of middle-class students, only arguing that educators can help poor students acquire the resources to stop being impoverished (such as useful friendships and emotional stability). Acknowledging and building upon diverse funds of knowledge is not only a more positive way to work with poor students and families, but also best practice. The deficit thinking model which Payne’s claims rest in is based on little research (and often, research that was taken out of context and used incorrectly). Not only are Payne’s claims insulting, offensive, and shocking, they are also extremely dangerous for educators teaching students from low socioeconomic backgrounds. Payne does not offer explanations for poverty (such the idea that the wealthy and middle-class often gain from the expense of less fortunate families) or suggest that teachers should help advocate for these families suffering from poverty - in fact, her claims suggest the poor, not poverty, as the issue at hand (Bomer 2525). As I was reading this critical analysis by Bomer, I kept wondering why Payne’s text has sold over 800,000 copies when the claims, rooted in generalizations and deficit thinking, seem so degrading. Critical theory’s components discussed by Sensoy and DiAngelo, including historical context of current social processes and institutions, process of socialization and its relationship to social stratification, and inequitable distribution of power and resources among social groups absolutely have a place in this discussion of poverty, but are not found in Payne’s text. For all of these reasons, I feel as if Bomer and other critics of Payne’s text are fair.

    I found myself thinking a lot about Payne’s statements within the text and how many people hold these same views without examining them further. I can admit that I have made assumption about people living in poverty and deficit thinking - I’ve also put a lot of effort into questioning my assumptions and educating myself further on issues. Questioning and researching are two crucial actions for educators. I am confident that I would have questioned a lot of Payne’s claims within this text and done further research to prove/disprove them. As educators, it is our job to shape our teaching practices based off of many texts and personal research that sometimes questions our beliefs.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I definitely feel that Payne’s critics are being more than fair in negatively evaluating her book. Not only did they bring light to the misinformation and false claims she wrote about, but they offered answers and deeper analysis into the issues in which Payne neglected. Honestly, her book seems to have the same effect as the “Bell Curve,” book, which only instilled negative stereotypes about African Americans even more. I do feel that Payne had good intentions in trying to help fellow educators, yet the way she went about it was unethical and offensive. For her to generalize a marginalized population in scholarly work is very shocking, yet not uncommon in the history of literature written about minority groups.
    I found it interesting to see Payne’s perspective on poor people, especially because I grew up poor and work with poor students. In fact, when I first started taking the poverty quiz, I stifled a laugh at some of the questions. It was obvious that the test was making general assumptions about the poor community as a whole. Unfortunately, the tasks on the list can “checked off” by wealthy people too. I agree that even though people in poverty are affected by these at much higher rates, this quiz inadvertently judges a whole class of citizens based on their income level. Her book also acknowledged popular opinions and views on the way we see, treat, and help impoverished people. Although her claims were annoying, it was interesting to see her claims align with the claims of politicians nowadays… *cough cough*
    My opinions on deficit thinking seem very broad and a bit confusing to put into words but I see it as this: I believe that trauma, which affects the brain, is what can make poor people to seem less intellectual. Trauma can affect people of any race, class, or gender, but particularly those who come from high stress environments, such as low-income communities. I do feel that those in poverty come from disadvantages, but those can be traced to years of oppression, institutionalized racism, and discrimination. I feel that instead of blaming African Americans and other minorities for their situations, our society as a whole needs to retrace our steps, admit to past/current inequities, and fix the real issues that those in poverty struggle with on a daily basis.
    -Chloe Berry

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is Chloe Berry's post (idk why it doesn't show my name lol)

      Delete
    2. I completely agree with what you said about politicians now a days. I think what it comes down to is no one wants to take responsibility. It's easy to say that someone is at fault for their life and that they have everything in their power to change their SES, but it isn't quite that easy. Especially with how many people view poor people in the same way that Payne describes them. As you mentioned, it becomes about "checking things off a list" which isn't indicative of someone.

      Delete
  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Coming from a background of psychology and learning about how to conduct scientific research, I believe that Payne’s critics are fair. Payne lays out many assumptions with practically no research to back them up. I found it interesting when she mentions the hidden values of being poor, but doesn’t describe where these come from, how they are formed, and the implication of these hidden values. She simply says that as educators, we should impose the hidden values of the middle class, instead of trying to understand the hidden values of the poor class. Unfortunately, I think that the views that Payne discusses in her book often mirrors how society views poverty or people who appear to be under a certain SES. I remember once when I told someone I wanted to teach in Richmond, I was asked why I wanted to teach “those kids” (rather than the affluent children I grew up with in suburban Chesterfield County). The problem with this viewpoint is that it simplifies people into broad categories and it seems that Payne’s assumptions put the blame on the person, rather than some of the mechanisms of power we discussed in class. It also asserts that the solution is to teach society how to conform to the supposed ideals of the middle and upper classes while ignoring the problems and roots of poverty. It’s the difference between teaching mainstream academic knowledge and teaching transformative knowledge. I like that Payne mentions that teachers should think about their background when teaching, but I’m not a fan of the way she has teachers use that information. To me, it sounds like Payne is saying that it’s a teacher's job to provide information and resources to students to change their views and ideals. However, it’s our job as teachers to provide information and resources to students in a way that both values their home and background and empowers them. It should give them choice, not force them to think based off how the teacher thinks. Furthermore, Payne’s assumptions makes it seem like poor children have nothing to offer, only information to learn. In some ways, it seems like Payne’s assumption reinforces the social stratifications that are apparent in society.

    One aspect of the article that stood with me while reading was the success of this program. It’s quite alarming that a program, created on practically no research, can have so much success. It’s a reminder to always be aware of the information that we are consuming and planning to use in our teaching. While it is important to remain up to date on the newest research, it’s equally as important to ensure that what we are consuming is quality, well-supported information. Just as we would ensure that our students are reading quality literature, teachers should follow the same rule. Additionally, teaching is a job that requires an open mindset. One has to be willing to be prepared for anything and to be receptive to many different scenarios. If a teacher is viewing the school system and its students through Payne’s viewpoints, I can’t imagine how hindering the teacher would be to his or her students.

    I think to a certain extent everyone has viewed another group of individuals through a deficit-way of thinking. For me, I know I fell into this thinking a lot growing up. I have always considered myself middle class, even when my mom was a single parent. In many ways, I have never known what it is like to struggle. I have always had some type of safety net, whether it be emotionally or financially, to fall back on. For me, the deficit thinking occurs easily with clothing. Clothing is one of the strongest factors with first impressions. It’s easy to see someone with sagging pants and unclean clothes and assume certain stereotypes. As I grew up and began to love science, I learned about the power of first impressions and how we can change deficit thinking into a thought process that ultimately benefits and values the students.

    -Alexis Wilkes

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Girl, you were in my head! I was about to type mine and read this and thought, "She literally just took all of the words out of my mouth!" The following statement(s) are key: "To me, it sounds like Payne is saying that it’s a teacher's job to provide information and resources to students to change their views and ideals. However, it’s our job as teachers to provide information and resources to students in a way that both values their home and background and empowers them. It should give them choice, not force them to think based off how the teacher thinks." This is vital because society's main goal is to transform someone into someone they are not. This provides these young kids with a lack of respect of who they are. The critic was being fair. I believe that fairness also relates to your morals and values, but doesn't everything? (definitely the theme of this class lol). But one of our jobs as teachers is to teach. One of our other jobs is to learn. Like you said, Payne insinuated that students from impoverished areas have nothing to offer, but only have to learn/gain. She's giving me prideful vibes.

      I also grew up middle class. My father on the other hand grew up in the hood of DC. He wanted to make sure that he created an environment to where we did have to go through what he went through. Even with the exposure of my extended family members, I still fell victim to deficit thinking. I quickly stereotyped people based off of what they wore and who they hung out with.

      Delete
    2. Sabrina Evans

      Delete
  16. While Payne's critics seemed harsh, there is truth to their point. It seems that Payne's book may not have as much research and studies done that it should have explored. Many assumptions were made, but I did think that the quiz we took was eye opening, and thought maybe Payne's book would be too. Obviously, no matter what class a person comes from, they will make assumptions about other classes they do not belong to, because they don't have close experience with each class, but it doesn't mean that one shouldn't educate themselves to try to eliminate those assumptions. We recently had an experience in our Home and School collab. class that proved to me that I may not have had assumptions or preconceived notions about different areas of Richmond, but it made me realize that I was extremely unaware and uneducated about where others come from. I know I may have had some harmless assumptions, or I may have just never given any thought to things I didn't see and therefore wasn't aware of, but as a future teacher I want to be aware. Aware of where my students come from, and also mindful of facts and real experiences, rather than assumptions.

    -Katie Fulton

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Katie,
      I really liked that you mentioned the quiz we took before hand. When reading the article and looking back at the quiz I thought it was really interesting that is came from Payne. I remember going through some of the statements for the middle class and saying well you don't have to do all these things to be part of the middle class. I really didn't like that for the poverty quiz it didn't have anything about like knowing where to find the best deals for grocery stores because the quiz suggested that in order to survive poverty you'd need to know how to use food stamps but just assumed that people living in poverty didn't actually shop for groceries instead they looked in garbage bins. When I found out from the reading that Payne only had three economic classes it made sense why some thoughts like that went through my mind. It was really strange that there was nothing to address, could you survive being a part of the working poor.

      Before taking the quiz I expected some of the statements for the middle class quiz to be "do you have transportation to a job" "do you have a college degree" but rather than focusing on survival/ making an income, providing food for your family to depend on it felt more like can you fit in with the middle class- the reason why I thought this it asks if you know where to buy the best brands that your family likes and if you can order at a nice restaurant but that didn't really seen like a skill you needed to survive? I'm not really sure, in my family those weren't things we worried about to survive. I can totally see how they are useful skills but they wouldn't have made my list of skills you need to survive I suppose. In contrast the poverty quiz had statements like, I can get by without a car, I know which churches have the best rummage sales which I think focused more on these skills are what I need to provide for myself/ family.

      - Jessica Diaz

      Delete
  17. Bomer states “At its root, deficit thinking holds that students who struggle or fail in school do so because of their own internal deficits or deficiencies”. I think this article did a good job of exposing how deficit thinking was found throughout Payne’s text. I was really shocked that Payne’s work was hardly supported by research and that so many people actually turned to this text as a way of learning about urban students. I think this article was illuminating because although Payne did not use the term deficit thinking, and I truly believe Payne didn’t see herself putting forth deficit thinking, it is still present throughout the text and in educational theory its very dangerous to public education to have people ignore institutional forces that also play a role in urban students academic performance. I found it interesting that Payne had three economic classes being poor, middle class, and upper class. I liked that Bomer had explained that in academia that no one would categorize economic classes in only three classes however I think that Bomer could have done a better job at addressing that in reality many people do only see three classes, and thats probably why this book resonated with so many people. I commented on Katie post to describe my experience with the pre quiz, its interesting that Bomer stated that 40% of people did not fit into the three socioeconomic classes and I could see how since I felt that it was hard to survive in any of the three classes and ideally everyone is supposed to fit somewhere. I think to many people there isn’t an understanding of what the working poor is and therefore Payne’s text that perpetuates stereotypes such laziness and unemployed among poor families. I think that deficit thinking makes people believe that teachers are miracle workers and that Payne’s book will help teachers learn the right way to teach and those who fail do so because of their mindset. This is really dangerous because it ignores that there is a structural issue regarding the pedagogy urban education

    I think deficit thinking has been present in my own thinking by believing that some of the experiences I had as a student in public schools at the middle school and high school would be similar to my experience as a teacher in urban schools. One example is that I assumed that guidance counselors in all high schools helped students create career and educational goals in addition to counseling students. I learned last year that the Future Centers in the RPS high schools were created to address the fact that the roles for guidance consolers were much different than the roles I understood as a student. I’m really happy to be in this program because I want to be more aware of my own biases and deficit thinking that I haven’t fully thought out yet.

    - Jessica Diaz

    ReplyDelete
  18. Payne’s “Could You Survive in…” quizzes were a little strange. Right off the bat, something rubbed me the wrong way about them. First, several of the “skills” seem totally outdated: “I know how to get a library card” and “I support or buy the work of a particular artist” (thanks to the internet, art has become far more accessible). Second, many of the items in the list of “poverty skills” seem like polar extremes, as though homeless people and working class people were grouped under “poverty”. For example, knowing what problems to look for in a used car, versus dumpster diving for food seem to me like skills belonging to very differently privileged groups of people. Besides that, there were a number of “skills” listed under “poverty” that could just as easily apply to “middle class”, and vice versa: “I can entertain a group of friends with my personality and my stories”. Overall, the lists felt more like exaggerated caricatures you’d find in some comedy. (Also, what in the world does knowing how to use a knife as scissors have to do with SES??)

    Upon reading Bomer et al’s analysis of Payne’s influential A Framework for Understanding Poverty, I felt some of my suspicions were validated. According to Bomer et al, Payne’s book (which has widely influenced education in America) is filled with pretty extreme claims about people living in poverty, with little to no evidence to back them up. I feel that in order for me to give a more objective opinion on their review, I’d have to read to book in question as well as check Bomer et al’s sources. However, based on the analysis and apparently extensive evidence provided by Bomer et al, it appears that Payne paints a rather dated, ignorant and harmful image of people living in poverty.

    The first point that really stuck out to me was the fact that Payne had broken people down into three very broad categories: wealth, middle class, and poverty. The first issue is that this is an incredibly limited approach, especially since Payne seems to include everyone from the working class to the homeless in the poverty group (which I had suspected when I took the aforementioned quiz). Bomer et al point out that no sociologists have ever used only three SES categories. At the very least they usually include the working class as a separate group; however, sociologists tend to identify or acknowledge further stratifications within each of these SES classes. Payne’s overly simplistic approach to classification is at the very least confusing and somewhat alienating- it’s like she puts anyone who is below the middle class, regardless of what income, lifestyle, etc. they have, into their own, distant corner.

    Going through Bomer et al’s extensive break down of Payne’s book showed stereotype after stereotype. While some of her points or claims might be useful or applicable to education to some extent, her overall focus was a fairly toxic view of people living under her definition of poverty. Payne repeatedly pushed ideas of victim blaming by making unfounded claims that echoed the concept of “deficit thinking”- a school of thought that essentially states poor people are poor thanks to their own behavior and life choices. While I do believe that most people can control their own futures to a certain degree, Payne appears to completely ignore the myriad of external and systemic factors that influence peoples’ lives/opportunities.

    (Part 1. Continued in next comment.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. (Part 2 below.)

      One point that really astounded and infuriated me was that Payne evidently used very few citations, most of which were not research or did not say what Payne claimed they said. Even more infuriating was that she repeatedly used the term “data” to describe her baseless claims. In my opinion this is outright and intentional misrepresentation and advertising. This abuse of citations, lack of evidence and intentional misuse of scientifically-specific vocabulary should be more than enough reason to throw out Payne’s entire book- these are typically the red flags of fraudulent research/claims.

      If I were to base my current opinion of Payne’s work solely upon Bomer et al’s analysis, I’d say I’m pretty disturbed by the fact that Payne’s work has played such a large role in American education. From Bomer et al’s assessment, Payne’s teachings perpetuate stereotypes and promote views that create rifts between teachers and students. Her framework places all the blame for SES on students and their families, while simultaneously making it teachers’ responsibility to essentially re-socialize individuals. For one, this places an unrealistic expectation on teachers and schools. But moreover, this is a viewpoint that dehumanizes and alienates a broad swath of human beings (according to Payne’s SES classifications).

      It appears that Payne’s focus is on the inadequacies of low SES students and their families. Upon a brief search for information about Randy Bomer, his approach to education revolves around the various strengths that students have, with a focus on students living in poverty. A look at the other authors of this review show that they have a similar school of thought and do not support the “deficit perspective”.

      Delete
  19. I believe payne’s critics are justified. To teach educators in a thought process like deficit thinking, does not benefit anyone, except maybe the wealthy and upper middle class. To focus all of your efforts on one student, not because you see potential in them, but instead because you have been taught to not see potential in others is exactly how a child gets left behind. This was illuminating to me because Payne’s school of thought, in my opinion, is a dangerous one that has been perpetuated for awhile now. However, I did not believe it to be so wide spread. Too many times have I heard someone attribute a child's poor performance or the status of someone’s life, to being “lazy” or “violent”. These thoughts and beliefs have come from family members and friends but I never humanized them in the sense that these could be the beliefs of our teachers. Obviously, someone who has gone so far as to write a book on the subject has thought critically on the topic, but theories are just that, theories. Theories are often proved wrong and in this case the common theory, contrary to payne’s, is now that there is much more at play than a common mindset. People in a similar SES may find themselves sharing a certain mentality, but this mentality is brought on by a slew of institutional and societal factors. I will admit that when I was younger I was guilty of this type of thinking. I grew up listening to my grandparents ramble on about how no one is willing to work these days and it's because they are lazy in nature. I like to think that once I was educated and was presented all of the information I completely snapped out of it. In hindsight I saw it that it took awhile for me to grasp the concept. Understanding, that yes I worked hard, but I did not face the same obstacles as others; and that everyone wants to do their best in life but it’s harder for some.

    -Adam Darby

    ReplyDelete
  20. The evidence presented by the author’s highlighted fair critiques of Payne’s work. Payne’s emphasis on the culture of poverty creates an environment that breads the usage of negative stereotypes to explain the low performance of SES students. For example, Payne’s characterization of the poor as being indifferent to criminality and incarceration support the negative stereotype of all poor people being criminals. She opens the door for those in low SES status to being characterized as “lazy, sex-crazed, criminals, who create their problems in life.”
    Her book reminded me of many of the ethnographers and anthropologist from 1890s to 1930s, who studied many indigenous people or “less developed” people in Latin America, Africa and Southeast Asia. The ethnographers and anthropologist approached their studies with a façade of scientific perspective but typically wrote deeply flawed findings or studies, like measuring craniums to determine intelligence. However, many of studies presented ethnocentric and sanctimonious “findings” about those “alien” cultures because the “researchers” lacked perspective and pluralism. In many ways, Payne’s work displayed similar features to those “researchers” because she seemed so out of touch with the people she “studied.” Additionally, another red flag the critics raised was the lack of detailed and substantial evidence supporting Payne’s claim. Any statement as bold as Payne’s must be supported in detail with evidence.
    However, I think poverty cannot solely be blamed on the system that perpetuates it. I think the educational, political, and social system, in American, creates systemic poverty but at some point, the poor individuals can foster poverty through the culture of poverty, as Payne attempted to explain. For example, last Friday I spent time at Armstrong High School and some of the students displayed attitudes of hopelessness and self-fulfilling prophecies. Because Armstrong lacks accreditation, a few of the students felt graduating high school would bring them few benefits. Those same students displayed less interest in doing their work. Firstly, this shows the system (i.e. heavy emphasis on standardized tests and the politics of school accreditation) creates this mindset in the students. At the same time, this example highlights a broken system cannot entirely explain the failures of high SES schools because individual mindset does, in my opinion, play a role in school performance. However, I should stress that I refuse the notion of the poor being solely responsible for their plight. Furthermore, I add that the individual’s actions represent a minority reason for low student achievement in high SES areas. Rather, I would argue that the root causes of poverty could be explained both through problems of both the individual’s mindset and the endemic system of poverty.
    Without a doubt, I am guilty of deficit thinking at times. I have blamed the individual for creating their misfortune, rather than the system and institutions around them. However, this usually occurs when I have a very personal relationship (i.e. Family members and close friends) with the individual because I see their actions up close. Additionally, as mentioned above, I am critical of the notion of all problems being explained through a corrupt system. Yes, a corrupt system explains many of the problems of low student achievement in high SES areas but I also believe in personal accountability for one’s actions. However, the emphasis of agency of one’s life is only pertinent in the secondary and specifically the high school level. I think it’s a slippery slope to polarize to one direction. As mentioned above, deficit thinking encourages negative stereotypes of students and the poor. Additionally, I think blaming everything on the system makes personal accountability and creating boundaries difficult to implement. In my opinion, boundaries help create areas for improvement.

    -Tyler Arnold

    ReplyDelete
  21. Payne’s critics are ABSOLUTELY being fair. First, it is absurd that Ruby Payne presumed to tell others how to teach children from poverty, especially under the pretense of an expert enlightening other educators, but what’s possibly more irresponsible is that her book was so widely accepted by professional development workshops. Payne essentially rambles on peddling her personal elitist and classist views as fact. As her critics mention repeatedly, none of her claims are founded in research, or even reality. This should be the primary cause for concern when reading or studying any of Payne’s work. Payne is a self-proclaimed expert with little evidence and many biases.

    Initially, I wanted to criticize Payne because she discusses poverty at length without even mentioning the possible role of race, ethnicity, and/or gender. She does list the ethnicity of the individuals in her “case studies” though, which most happen to be people of color. I agree with the article that she uses this tactic to portray the majority of the impoverished as minorities while perpetuating negative stereotypes. Payne feigns a colorblind policy when it comes to her tactics, but makes the point of mentioning color when it seems to prove her point. She also seems to purposefully omit race or culture when it would contradict her point, such as the examples about circumlocution being a characteristic of African language, not poverty.

    After conducting some of my own research, her omission of race from her literature about children in poverty is one of her more criticized actions. One hundred percent of the negative Amazon reviews about her book are based on her “tendency to perpetuate stereotypes”, “bigoted propaganda”, and “an ideology that continues to contribute to the marginalization of disenfranchised groups”. Clearly this sort of criticism is a common occurrence for Payne because she has posted an essay on her own website (ahaprocess.com) that addresses the criticism. She writes that time is limited, meaning not all topics can be discussed and that she chooses to focus on economic diversity and class issues. Payne also describes that a myriad of factors contribute to the relationship between race and poverty, mostly depending on the minorities in a given geographical region. However, she concludes her rebuttal by conceding that she is not informed enough to discuss race in particular and that she believes that “audiences and readers have access to the best expertise available”, which is in direct contradiction to the fact that her entire book is unsubstantiated and has no basis in fact or reality. The irony is thick.

    ReplyDelete
  22. The critique of Payne’s work is definitely fair. The authors systematically go through her stereotypical and negative claims and give the support she didn’t provide to show the lack of evidence for her claims. Payne makes claims about people in poverty and how to teach these students that perpetuates the problem. They allow herself and others that are in the dominant group to put the blame on people in poverty for their circumstances. It seems Payne provides no data or evidence that supports her claims, while her critics dispute her unjust claims with research.

    It was shocking to hear of all schools and teachers that have read Payne’s work and blindly support it. As teachers, we have the power to negatively influence our children with the deficit approach that Payne groundlessly promotes. While the stereotypes and claims promoted in Payne’s work aren’t supported and are in fact denounced by her critics in the article we read, the teachers and schools that are taking her claims as truth and treating their students based on her thoughts are impacting these children negatively. Your mind is so powerful and when we as teachers go out with a deficit mindset when dealing with any of our students, we are projecting that onto them and cultivating a negative mindset in them. Nurturing our students to believe in themselves and work hard for their goals is more effective than treating them like they are already set up for failure as Payne suggests. This is a huge reminder to research whomever is trying to inform you.

    ReplyDelete
  23. The article upsets me. Payne’s critics illustrate a person who is largely oblivious to the current social inequalities in today’s world. I agree, any work that proceeds to negatively stereotype and provide a limited picture of those in poverty should be critically examined. The critics shine a light on a body of work that has been widely excepted, but slips under the radar disguised as a way to help. To sum up the critics, Payne’s bestseller, Framework for Understanding Poverty: focuses on an individual’s deficits and not the systems that cause poverty, stereotype people living in poverty, and provides little evidence to show that the techniques used in the book work.

    What is so illuminating about Payne’s work, is how wide spread and indoctrinated it has become in various circles. Her work, which I believe was well intentioned, assumes that poverty is a state of mind, and that those with this state of mind can transmit it throughout one’s household. This idea is parallel to how her own is transmitted, and pointed towards teachers who want to get a better picture of the students they teach to help them. What makes this approach dangerous is that the beliefs in the classroom are often dictated by the teacher. From the teacher, these beliefs are passed onto the student, creating a negative influence. A phrase tossed around by the critics, deficit thinking, is the underlying message of Payne’s work. It serves as the poison to those in poverty.

    Deficit thinking argues that students who struggle or fail, do so because of their internal deficiencies. It places significant fault on the individual. It ignores the fact that the individual makes up only a piece. The other pieces are external, and they take many different forms.

    In the past, I have been quick to stereotype, or single out a student because of their bad behavior. The reason being is that it’s easy. To me, it was easy to ignore the student’s life at home. It was easy to ignore how the student’s school was organized. It was easy to ignore the inequalities in his schools funding and lack of resources. It is easy to take things at face value, and see them in black and white.

    Kieran Wilkinson

    ReplyDelete
  24. The critics are fair. That is the whole point of this paper; critics are critically looking into this book so that people will not get the wrong message. I looked up Ruby Payne's and found that she hold a Ph.D. She did not check her privilege at the front of the page. I can't believe it is on 360 selling list on amazon.com. Critics pointed out that Payne's audiences are mostly white, females and middle class. In other words, she knows her audiences and she knows what they want to read.

    In Payne's defense, may of the claims were true. She just does not use the right words or know how to say it in a way that doesn't sound as stereotyping. For example, poor people know how to get a gun. She is talking about getting an unregistered gun on streets. The critics said that most gun owners are rich and they can buy a legal gun anytime they want.

    This article is useful in two-way. I was not born in American and I am still learning many things. Sadly, this article teaches me the stereotypes and the assumption around poor people. It is good to know and be aware of everything. On the positive side, critics provide me with real evidence that the stereotypes claims are incorrect.

    I needed to be in a deficit thinking mode because when I begin reading this article, I was not sure why I am reading this. I felt like I am reading a tweet from the president. Payne's claims were base on Hollywood movies, where most bad guys are people of color and poor. The book got published because it is self-publish. She targets the audiences that willing to buy her books. 800,000 copy sold and a single book that makes many millions of dollars. WOW!!!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Thurs. May 25

Tues. June 13

Thurs. June 8